P

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Provides auto, home, renters, condo insurance

Overview

Plymouth Rock Assurance offers auto, home, renters, and condo insurance across the Northeast through a network of employees and Independent Agents. It underwrites policies and provides claims support and service to protect customers’ vehicles and properties. The company differentiates itself with a strong workplace culture, community involvement, and multiple regional awards. Its goal is to deliver reliable, high-quality protection and support to customers and communities while creating growth opportunities for employees and partners.

Work here?Claim your company

About Plymouth Rock Assurance

Simplify's Rating
Why Plymouth Rock Assurance is rated
C
Rated C on Competitive Edge
Rated C on Growth Potential
Rated C on Differentiation

Industries

Company Size

1,001-5,000

Company Stage

N/A

Total Funding

N/A

Headquarters

Boston, MA

Founded

1983

Get referred to Plymouth Rock Assurance

See people who can refer or advise you

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's take

What believers are saying

  • Chris Taylor returned September 23, 2026 to accelerate independent-agent growth.
  • October 2026 Encharter sale sharpened focus on core insurance operations and agent economics.
  • November 2, 2026 fraud-conference awards validate claims execution and anti-fraud capabilities.

What critics are saying

  • Marlin et al. v. Plymouth Rock Assurance filed October 7, 2026 in Pennsylvania threatens claims costs.
  • SIU referrals jumped 41% year over year; towing and storage referrals jumped 70%.
  • Selling Encharter after 25 years signals pruning assets, not building scale through acquisition.

What makes Plymouth Rock Assurance unique

  • Plymouth Rock’s ChatGPT home-quote plugin made it first U.S. carrier there on July 30, 2026.
  • It blends direct, agent, and independent-channel distribution across six Northeastern states.
  • The October 2026 campaign unifies Auto, Home, Direct, and Independent Agent brands.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Company News

GlobeNewswire
Nov 2nd, 2026
Plymouth Rock wins three top honors at New Jersey Special Investigators Association's 35th Annual Insurance Fraud Conference.

Plymouth Rock wins three top honors at New Jersey Special Investigators Association's 35th Annual Insurance Fraud Conference. Rich Mariani named Claims Executive of the Year; SIU team honored for Investigation of the Year; Patrick Golden named Claims Person of the Year. November 02, 2026 09:30 ET | Source: Plymouth Rock WOODBRIDGE, N.J., Nov. 02, 2026 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) - Plymouth Rock took home three major awards at the New Jersey Special Investigators Association (NJSIA) Annual Insurance Fraud Conference, held in Atlantic City during New Jersey's Insurance Fraud Awareness Month. Plymouth Rock was honored with: * Claims Executive of the Year: Rich Mariani, Vice President of Claims * Investigation of the Year: "Crash for Cash" case led by Ebony Logan, SIU Senior Investigator; James Marciano, SIU Analyst; Francesca Rametta, PIP Senior Claims Representative; and Ann Marie Demko, Casualty Senior Claims Representative * Claims Person of the Year: Patrick Golden, Appraisal Supervisor Now in its 35th year, the NJSIA conference brings together Special Investigations Units (SIUs), claim professionals, and law enforcement for training and collaboration on detecting and preventing insurance fraud. This year's event featured more than 25 exhibitors. For the second consecutive year, Plymouth Rock had the largest industry delegation, with more than 70 associates attending. "These awards reflect the dedication our Claims and SIU teams bring to protecting our policyholders every day," said Rick Adam, Chief Claims Officer, Plymouth Rock Management Company of New Jersey. "Fighting insurance fraud takes sharp investigators, strong collaboration across departments, and leaders who make it a priority. We're proud of Rich, Pat, and the investigation team, and grateful to NJSIA for recognizing their work." Claims Executive of the Year: Rich Mariani Mariani, based in Plymouth Rock's Woodbridge, New Jersey office, brings 40 years of leadership in the insurance claims industry. He oversees complex Personal Injury Protection (PIP), casualty, and property claims operations and has mentored many of the company's Claims leaders. Mariani is committed to strengthening Plymouth Rock's SIU investigations. He has championed the use of intelligence analysts, social media, and other web-based investigative tools which have helped support criminal indictments, civil penalties, and fraud actions through thorough, well-documented investigations. Mariani also takes a hands-on role in large and complex fraud ring investigations, providing strategic and tactical guidance and working with Claims management and counsel throughout the life of each case. An active NJSIA member, he regularly participates in the association's training events, conferences, and membership meetings. Investigation of the Year: "Crash for Cash" The Investigation of the Year award recognized the Plymouth Rock team who worked on a complex automobile fraud case involving two related claims with PIP and Bodily Injury (BI) coverage. The team was recognized for their coordinated, thorough, disciplined, and results-driven work. The case showed several fraud indicators, including losses shortly after policy inception, no police report, extensive prior claim activity among the parties, questionable vehicle ownership and licensing information, and early pressure for a BI settlement. Through detailed link analysis, Plymouth Rock's SIU Analyst, James Marciano was able to establish that the parties involved were connected to 42 industry claims. Claims Person of the Year: Patrick Golden Golden was recognized for his investigative skills and his work strengthening the detection of predatory towing and enhanced damage claims. Over the past year, SIU referrals involving questionable damage, towing and storage charges, and body shop concerns increased 41% compared with the prior year, and referrals involving towing and storage alone increased 70%. "Congratulations to all nominees and winners of these awards," concluded Adam. "We are all in this together. Insurance fraud can raise costs for our policyholders and puts a strain on the entire claims system. That's why we keep investing in training, technology, and partnerships with law enforcement and industry peers. It's how we protect our customers and help keep insurance affordable." About Plymouth Rock Plymouth Rock was established to offer its customers a higher level of service and a more innovative set of products and features than they would expect from an insurance company. Plymouth Rock's innovative approach puts customers' convenience and satisfaction first, giving them the choice to do business the way they want - online, using a mobile device, by phone or with one of Plymouth Rock's agents. Plymouth Rock Assurance(R) and Plymouth Rock(R) are brand names and service marks used by separate underwriting, managed insurance, and management companies that offer property and casualty insurance in multiple states pursuant to licensing arrangements. Taken together, the companies write and manage $2.5 billion in auto and home insurance premiums across Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania. Each underwriting and managed insurance company is a separate legal entity that is financially responsible only for its own insurance products. Actual coverage is subject to the language of the policy as issued. You can learn more about us by visiting plymouthrock.com.

Insurance Journal
Oct 22nd, 2026
Plymouth Rock sells Encharter agency to MountainOne.

Plymouth Rock sells Encharter agency to MountainOne. October 22, 2026 Plymouth Rock Assurance Co. has sold a western Massachusetts independent agency it bought more than 25 years ago. The buyer, MountainOne Insurance Agency, is owned by regional bank MountainOne Bank. The sale of Amherst-based Encharter Insurance Agency by Plymouth Rock was effective October 1, 2026. Terms were not disclosed. A fixture in the Amherst community since 1879 offering personal and commercial lines insurance, Encharter was formerly known as Blair, Cutting & Smith. As part of the acquisition, 22 Encharter insurance professionals join the MountainOne team, along with the agency's Amherst office and satellite location in Lexington. North Adams-based MountainOne Insurance Agency provides personal and business property and casualty insurance, surety bonding, employee benefits, life and Medicare coverage. The acquisition of the agency in Amherst establishes MountainOne's first insurance office in Hampshire County, continuing its expansion throughout the Pioneer Valley and adding to its local offices in Greenfield, Longmeadow, West Springfield, and Wilbraham, as well as communities throughout the Berkshires Since 1999 under Plymouth Rock Assurance's ownership, Encharter maintained its independent agency model and relationships with multiple insurance carriers. Encharter will gradually transition to the MountainOne Insurance Agency name and brand. Boston-based Plymouth Rock offers auto, home, condo, renters, and umbrella insurance across the six Northeastern states of Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania. Was this article valuable? Interested in mergers? Get automatic alerts for this topic.

PNI News
Oct 21st, 2026
MountainOne Insurance acquires Encharter Insurance Agency from Plymouth Rock, expanding into Hampshire County.

MountainOne Insurance acquires Encharter Insurance Agency from Plymouth Rock, expanding into Hampshire County. NORTH ADAMS, MA: MountainOne Insurance Agency, Inc. has acquired Amherst-based Encharter Insurance Agency from Plymouth Rock Assurance, effective October 1, 2026. The acquisition establishes MountainOne's first insurance office in Hampshire County, marking a significant step in its continued expansion throughout the Pioneer Valley. A fixture in the Amherst community since 1879, Encharter has served generations of individuals, families, and businesses for nearly 150 years. Formerly known as Blair, Cutting & Smith, the agency has built a strong reputation for its local expertise, longstanding customer relationships, and personalized service. As part of the acquisition, 22 Encharter insurance professionals join the MountainOne team, along with the agency's Amherst office and satellite location in Lexington. The acquisition marks a new chapter for Encharter following approximately 25 years under Plymouth Rock Assurance's ownership, during which the agency maintained its independent agency model and relationships with multiple insurance carriers. Joining MountainOne Insurance positions Encharter for its next chapter as part of a growing, locally rooted insurance organization with an expanding network of offices and services across Massachusetts. "What impressed me most about Encharter was the people and the reputation they've built over generations," said Jonathan Denmark, Executive Vice President of MountainOne Bank and President and Chief Operating Officer of MountainOne Insurance. "They've earned the trust of their customers and become an important part of the Amherst community. We want to build on that success, giving their team even more tools and resources to take care of the people who count on them. That's what makes this such an exciting opportunity for both organizations." For Encharter customers, the acquisition brings expanded insurance solutions while preserving the familiar faces and personal relationships that have long defined the agency. As the organizations integrate, customers will gain access to additional insurance carriers and services, including Employee Benefits, Surety Bonding, Life Insurance, Long-Term Care Insurance, and Medicare, along with dedicated in-house claims assistance. "I'm confident our customers will be in good hands with MountainOne, an organization that shares our commitment to personal service and lasting relationships," said Lisa Johnson, Chief Operating Officer of Encharter Insurance. "I'm incredibly proud of what our team has accomplished and the trust we've earned over the years. Joining MountainOne gives us an opportunity to build on that success together." The acquisition brings together two longstanding Massachusetts institutions. Founded in 1848, MountainOne has maintained its mutual values and commitment to local decision-making, community investment, and lasting relationships. Encharter joins MountainOne Insurance during a period of continued growth and industry recognition. MountainOne Insurance recently earned the prestigious Five Star Agency designation from the Massachusetts Association of Insurance Agents (MAIA), becoming one of just 15 agencies statewide to hold the distinction. The Amherst acquisition builds on MountainOne Insurance's growing footprint throughout western Massachusetts, adding Hampshire County to its established network of local offices in Greenfield, Longmeadow, West Springfield, and Wilbraham, as well as communities throughout the Berkshires. Encharter will gradually transition to the MountainOne Insurance Agency name and brand. Throughout the transition, customers will continue working with the insurance professionals they know and trust, while gaining access to expanded resources and services as the organizations integrate. Plans are also underway for a new Amherst office, underscoring MountainOne's long-term commitment to the community.

Plymouth Rock Assurance
Sep 29th, 2026
Plymouth Rock Home Assurance names Jared Stuckey VP of Customer Service and Underwriting.

Plymouth Rock Home Assurance names Jared Stuckey VP of Customer Service and Underwriting. BOSTON - Sept. 29, 2026 - Plymouth Rock Home Assurance Corporation has named Jared Stuckey Vice President of Customer Service and Underwriting, effective immediately. Stuckey led underwriting strategy and managed personal and commercial products for Plymouth Rock's Independent Agent auto business. He will now oversee both customer service and underwriting for the Home Insurance group. "Jared gets things done," said Bill Martin, President and CEO of Plymouth Rock Home Assurance Corporation, announcing Jared's promotion. "In 20-plus years across nearly every insurer function, he's built a track record of results. Our officers universally identified him as our highest potential manager. We are thrilled to have him here on the Home team." Before joining Plymouth Rock, Stuckey spent 16 years at Liberty Mutual, where he held a variety of senior roles in product management and customer experience. He is a graduate of Goshen College and holds an MBA from The Wharton School. "I'm excited for the opportunity to use my experience in customer experience and home insurance at a time when so much is evolving," said Stuckey. "The opportunities to innovate and enhance the customer experience are tremendous. Our agents are going to love the changes to come." About Plymouth Rock Plymouth Rock was established to offer its customers a higher level of service and a more innovative set of products and features than they would expect from an insurance company. Plymouth Rock's innovative approach puts customers' convenience and satisfaction first, giving them the choice to do business the way they want - online, using a mobile device, by phone or with one of Plymouth Rock's agents. Plymouth Rock Assurance(R) and Plymouth Rock(R) are brand names and service marks used by separate underwriting, managed insurance, and management companies that offer property and casualty insurance in multiple states pursuant to licensing arrangements. Taken together, the companies write and manage $2.5 billion in auto and home insurance premiums across Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania. Each underwriting and managed insurance company is a separate legal entity that is financially responsible only for its own insurance products. Actual coverage is subject to the language of the policy as issued. You can learn more about Plymouth Rock Company by visiting plymouthrock.com.

GlobeNewswire
Sep 23rd, 2026
Plymouth Rock Assurance Corporation names Chris Taylor President and Chief Executive Officer.

Plymouth Rock Assurance Corporation names Chris Taylor President and Chief Executive Officer. Industry veteran returns to Plymouth Rock to lead its Independent Agency Group's next chapter of growth. September 23, 2026 11:00 ET | Source: Plymouth Rock BOSTON, Sept. 23, 2026 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) - Plymouth Rock Assurance Corporation today announced that it has named Chris Taylor as President and Chief Executive Officer. He will lead Plymouth Rock's Independent Agency Group, effective Monday, October 12, 2026. The appointment reflects Plymouth Rock's continued investment in the independent agency channel, backed by Taylor's decade-plus track record of personal lines insurance leadership and deep experience in the agency channel. "We are thrilled to welcome Chris into his new role," said Jim Stone, Founder and Chairman of the Plymouth Rock Group. "Independent agents have always been central to Plymouth Rock's business, and Chris understands firsthand what it takes to build the strong, lasting partnerships that our business requires." Taylor brings personal lines leadership experience to the role, most recently as Vice President and Head of State Management at The Hanover Insurance Group, where he had P&L responsibility for auto, home, and ancillary lines. In that role, he built and strengthened independent agency relationships, expanded the company's portfolio, and led profitable countrywide growth. He helped bring several new products to market, including a successful high-net-worth offering. Before joining The Hanover, Taylor worked at Plymouth Rock, where he helped lead the company's entry into the New York and Pennsylvania auto insurance markets through the independent agency channel. He began his insurance career at The Hartford in Product Management. "Independent agents have been central to my career and to my view of how insurance is best delivered," said Taylor. "Agents know their clients, understand their communities and bring a level of personal guidance that is incredibly valuable to insurance shoppers. I'm excited to return to Plymouth Rock to work alongside a strong team and our agent partners, building on that strength and creating new opportunities to grow together." Taylor holds a BS in Chemistry from the University of Connecticut, an MS in Chemistry from the University of Illinois, and an MBA from the University of Connecticut. About Plymouth Rock Plymouth Rock was established to offer its customers a higher level of service and a more innovative set of products and features than they would expect from an insurance company. Plymouth Rock's innovative approach puts customers' convenience and satisfaction first, giving them the choice to do business the way they want - online, using a mobile device, by phone or with one of Plymouth Rock's agents. Plymouth Rock Assurance(R) and Plymouth Rock(R) are brand names and service marks used by separate underwriting, managed insurance, and management companies that offer property and casualty insurance in multiple states pursuant to licensing arrangements. Taken together, the companies write and manage $2.5 billion in auto and home insurance premiums across Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania. Each underwriting and managed insurance company is a separate legal entity that is financially responsible only for its own insurance products. Actual coverage is subject to the language of the policy as issued. You can learn more about us by visiting plymouthrock.com.

Recently Posted Jobs

Sign up to get curated job recommendations

Plymouth Rock Assurance is Hiring for 3 Jobs on Simplify!

Find jobs on Simplify and start your career today

Don't see your dream role? Check out thousands of other roles on Simplify.Browse all jobs