Full-Time

Senior Special Casualty Claims Investigator

Special Investigation Unit

Posted on 9/23/2025

Great American Insurance Company

Great American Insurance Company

1,001-5,000 employees

Specialized commercial property and casualty insurer

Compensation Overview

$85k - $100k/yr

Remote in USA

Remote

Category
Finance & Banking (1)
Required Skills
Risk Management
Data Analysis
Requirements
  • Experience handling a litigation case load of complex casualty claims.
  • Bachelor’s Degree in Criminal Justice, Risk Management and Insurance, Business Administration, or a related field or equivalent experience.
  • Generally, a minimum of 6 years of casualty claim handling experience with some Criminal Investigation or Fraud Detection experience.
  • Continuing progress toward and/or the completion of a professional designation preferred, such as Certified Insurance Fraud Investigator (CIFI), Certified Fraud Examiner, or Private Investigator license from a National Investigation Organization or State Agency.
Responsibilities
  • Detects and prevents fraudulent claims through meticulous investigation and complex analysis.
  • Analyzes and interprets data to identify inconsistencies, potential fraud, and the overall legitimacy of claims.
  • Prepares comprehensive reports summarizing investigation findings and recommends claim approval or denial. Evaluates claims and may recommend courses of action to management.
  • Ensures claims are settled accurately and fairly, minimizing fraudulent activities and protecting the company’s financial interests.
  • May present evidence and/or deliver testimony in situations where law enforcement agencies seek prosecution.
  • Contributes to the continuous improvement of investigation processes and techniques, enhancing overall efficiency and effectiveness.
  • May contribute to the development of program awareness initiatives or facilitate training sessions focused on the detection, deterrence, and prevention of fraudulent activities.
  • Performs other duties as assigned.
Desired Qualifications
  • Continuing progress toward and/or the completion of a professional designation preferred, such as Certified Insurance Fraud Investigator (CIFI), Certified Fraud Examiner, or Private Investigator license from a National Investigation Organization or State Agency.
Great American Insurance Company

Great American Insurance Company

View

Great American Insurance Company is part of American Financial Group and focuses on property and casualty insurance for businesses. It offers specialty commercial insurance products through the Great American Insurance Group, targeting niche markets with tailored coverage. The product works by underwriting insurance policies that transfer specific business risks to the insurer in exchange for premiums, backed by risk management practices and claims handling. The company differentiates itself by concentrating on specialized, non-standard commercial lines rather than broad consumer or mass-market coverage, and by combining underwriting discipline with an invested portfolio to support results. Its goal is to provide targeted insurance solutions to businesses and manage risk and capital to generate stable financial returns.

Company Size

1,001-5,000

Company Stage

IPO

Headquarters

Cincinnati, Ohio

Founded

1872

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • Crop insurance expansion leverages 1915 operations across 40 states.
  • Over 150 years of relationships enable premium pricing and low loss ratios.
  • Annuity cross-selling expands financial services to P&C customers.

What critics are saying

  • Hurricanes erode P&C margins with rising Southeast claims in 6-12 months.
  • Chubb captures 15% share using digital tools in 12-24 months.
  • 2025 Farm Bill slashes crop premiums 25% in 3-6 months.

What makes Great American Insurance Company unique

  • Great American Insurance Company specializes in niche commercial P&C products since 1872.
  • Great American Crop Insurance offers private crop policies authorized by USDA RMA.
  • Deep underwriting expertise in cyber, environmental, and supply chain risks.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

Health Insurance

Dental Insurance

Vision Insurance

Paid Vacation

Paid Holidays

Commuter Benefits

Employee Stock Purchase Plan

Education Reimbursement

Paid Parental Leave

Adoption Assistance

401(k) Retirement Plan

401(k) Company Match

Company News

Yahoo Finance
Mar 5th, 2026
AFG misses Q4 revenue estimates despite strong property & casualty insurance sector performance

HCI Group led property and casualty insurers in Q4, reporting revenues of $246.2 million, up 52.1% year on year and beating analyst expectations by 3.8%. The Florida-focused homeowners insurer delivered an impressive quarter, exceeding estimates for both book value per share and earnings per share. The 37 property and casualty insurance stocks tracked reported a strong Q4 overall, with revenues beating analyst consensus estimates by 5% as a group. Share prices have remained relatively stable following the earnings announcements. American Financial Group posted revenues of $1.96 billion, down 3.2% year on year, missing analyst expectations by 2.8%. Despite the mixed results, AFG's stock has risen 2% since reporting and currently trades at $132.82.

Business Wire
Feb 17th, 2026
American Financial Group management to participate in 2026 AIFA conference

American Financial Group (AFG) announced that Co-Chief Executive Officers Carl H. Lindner III and S. Craig Lindner, along with Chief Financial Officer Brian S. Hertzman, will participate in the 2026 Association of Insurance and Financial Analysts Conference on 2 March 2026. The Cincinnati-based insurance holding company will not give a formal presentation but will host several investor meetings. Materials for these meetings will be posted on AFG's investor relations webpage prior to the conference. AFG operates through Great American Insurance Group, focusing on specialised commercial property and casualty insurance products for businesses. Great American Insurance Company, the group's flagship, was founded in 1872.

Yahoo Finance
Feb 3rd, 2026
American Financial Group beats Q4 revenue estimates with $2.06B, EPS of $3.65 tops forecasts by 10%

American Financial Group reported fourth-quarter revenue of $2.06 billion, up 1.8% year-on-year and exceeding analyst estimates of $2.02 billion. The insurance holding company's non-GAAP earnings of $3.65 per share beat consensus expectations by 10.1%. However, net premiums earned fell 2.4% to $1.81 billion, missing estimates of $1.83 billion. Pre-tax profit reached $379 million with an 18.4% margin, whilst book value per share rose 8.6% year-on-year to $57.78. The company, which specialises in commercial property and casualty insurance through Great American Insurance Group, has seen revenue growth slow to 4.1% annually over the past two years, below its five-year compound annual growth rate of 8.2%. Net premiums account for 90.3% of total revenue.

Yahoo Finance
Feb 3rd, 2026
American Financial reports Q4 earnings of $3.65 per share, beating Wall Street expectations

American Financial Group reported fourth-quarter profit of $299 million, or $3.65 per share on an adjusted basis, exceeding Wall Street expectations of $3.18 per share. The Cincinnati-based property and casualty insurer posted adjusted revenue of $2.02 billion for the quarter. For the full year, the company reported profit of $842 million, or $10.08 per share, with revenue of $7.91 billion. American Financial shares have declined roughly 5% since the beginning of the year, trading at $130.25 in Tuesday's final minutes, down almost 5% over the past 12 months.

The AI Journal Ltd
Jan 27th, 2026
American Financial Group Management to Participate in the BofA Securities 2026 Financial Services Conference

American Financial Group management to participate in the BofA Securities 2026 Financial Services Conference. CINCINNATI - (BUSINESS WIRE) - American Financial Group, Inc. (NYSE: AFG) announced today that Carl H. Lindner III and S. Craig Lindner, Co-Chief Executive Officers, and Brian S. Hertzman, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, will participate in the BofA Securities 2026 Financial Services Conference on Tuesday, February 10, 2026. While there will be no Company presentation, AFG will host several investor meetings. The investor material to be used in the meetings will be posted via a link under Events on the Investor Relations page of AFG's website, www.AFGinc.com, just prior to the conference. American Financial Group is an insurance holding company, based in Cincinnati, Ohio. Through the operations of Great American Insurance Group, AFG is engaged primarily in property and casualty insurance, focusing on specialized commercial products for businesses. Great American Insurance Group's roots go back to 1872 with the founding of its flagship company, Great American Insurance Company.

INACTIVE