Full-Time

Senior Manager

Performance Marketing Strategy

Posted on 7/31/2025

EverQuote

EverQuote

201-500 employees

Lead-generation marketplace connecting consumers with insurers

No salary listed

Cambridge, MA, USA

In Person

Category
Growth & Marketing (3)
, ,
Required Skills
Data Analysis
Requirements
  • 6–10 years of experience in paid media with a focus on upper-funnel channel management (e.g., CTV, Paid Social, Programmatic Video)
  • Experience managing direct reports and building high-performing marketing teams
  • Proven success launching and scaling new performance channels from concept to maturity
  • Deep understanding of media buying, targeting, measurement, and attribution in both brand and performance contexts
  • Strong background in audience strategy, creative testing, and cross-channel campaign orchestration
  • Analytical mindset with comfort interpreting complex data to inform strategy and optimization
  • Exceptional project management and cross-functional communication skills
Responsibilities
  • Own the full-funnel Performance Media strategy, from targeting and audiences through site experience
  • Bridge the gap between ad creatives and on-site experience to drive optimal performance and outcomes
  • Leverage AI tools and platforms to automate and enhance audience targeting, creative development, media buying, and performance optimization
  • Partner with the Performance Media Analytics team to identify, test, and scale new upper-funnel performance marketing channels (e.g., Paid Social, Video, CTV, and other emerging platforms)
  • Build a multi-channel strategy roadmap aligned with business growth goals, prioritizing impact, reach, and efficiency
  • Develop frameworks to evaluate channel potential, performance benchmarks, and test structures for ongoing expansion
  • Partner with analytics to ensure proper tracking and attribution for new channels
  • Define and implement robust audience segmentation strategies tailored to different personas and marketing objectives
  • Use data to identify high-value audience segments across first-party, third-party, and platform-specific targeting capabilities
  • Collaborate with Analytics, Design and Product to enhance targeting precision and personalization
  • Continuously optimize and refine audience segments based on performance
  • Own the creative briefing process for each channel, ensuring concepts align with channel best practices, target audience insights, and brand tone
  • Partner with in-house and external creative teams to develop assets tailored to each stage of the funnel
  • Champion testing methodologies to refine messaging, visual treatments, and calls to action
  • Establish a library of high-performing creative by audience and channel
  • Set KPIs and track performance across all upper-funnel channels (e.g., CPM, VCR, CTR, Brand Lift, incremental reach, assisted conversions)
  • Partner with analytics to build dashboards and insight reports that drive strategic recommendations
  • Iterate on campaign structure, bidding strategies, targeting, and creative based on performance insights
  • Manage media budgets, pacing, and forecasting with a focus on ROI and long-term growth
  • Work closely with Analytics, Product, and Remarketing teams to align messaging and campaign goals across the funnel
  • Regularly share results, learnings, and recommendations with senior stakeholders
  • Build and manage relationships with external media vendors, agencies, and platforms

EverQuote operates an online insurance marketplace that connects consumers with insurance providers. It helps individuals seeking policies for homes, cars, and families find and compare options through a digital platform. Users input personal details and insurance needs; the platform prequalifies them and matches them with suitable insurers in their area, enabling side-by-side comparisons so customers can choose the best option. Revenue comes from a lead-generation model in which insurers pay EverQuote for the leads generated through the platform. The company also uses interest-based advertising to show targeted ads based on collected user data. The goal is to make insurance shopping easier, faster, and more affordable by using technology to pair consumers with relevant insurance options and providers.

Company Size

201-500

Company Stage

IPO

Headquarters

Cambridge, Massachusetts

Founded

2010

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • Home insurance revenue grew 33% to $18.5M in Q1 2026, outpacing auto growth.
  • All major carriers active on platform, including top-five carrier returning in Q1 2026.
  • Record $29.6M operating cash flow in Q1 2026 enables $1B revenue target in 2-3 years.

What critics are saying

  • Google's AI tools in Search and Gemini cut aggregator traffic 40% within 6-12 months.
  • The Zebra's direct quoting from Progressive and Geico slashes referral fees in 12-18 months.
  • CCPA enforcement fines EverQuote $10M+ and halves leads via opt-ins in 6-12 months.

What makes EverQuote unique

  • EverQuote uses machine learning from 2011 AdHarmonics roots to match consumer intent with underwriting criteria in real-time.
  • Platform processes millions of quote requests annually across auto, home, and life insurance lines.
  • Lead generation model earns referral fees without direct quoting or paid inclusions in recommendations.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

Flexible Work Hours

Hybrid Work Options

Performance Bonus

Pension plan

Health Insurance

Dental Insurance

Vision Insurance

Enhanced parental leave

Work From Home Allowance

Growth & Insights and Company News

Headcount

6 month growth

-1%

1 year growth

0%

2 year growth

-2%
Yahoo Finance
Apr 14th, 2026
TD SYNNEX grows revenue 25.6% annually while EverQuote and ANI Pharmaceuticals struggle with inefficiencies

TD SYNNEX, a global technology distributor serving as a middleman in the IT supply chain, stands out amongst cash-producing companies with a trailing 12-month free cash flow margin of 1.9%. The company has demonstrated strong fundamentals with annual revenue growth of 25.6% over the past five years and a massive revenue base of $65.14 billion. Share buybacks have driven earnings per share growth to 15.6%, outpacing revenue gains over the last two years. In contrast, online insurance marketplace EverQuote faces challenges with high marketing expenses suggesting heavy customer acquisition costs, whilst ANI Pharmaceuticals struggles with a modest revenue base of $883.4 million, declining operating margins, and negative returns on capital indicating failed growth strategies.

Yahoo Finance
Mar 13th, 2026
EverQuote hits Q4 record but analysts cut price targets on cautious 2026 outlook

EverQuote's analyst fair value has edged from $23.83 to $24.17 following strong Q4 results, though multiple firms have lowered price targets amid tempered growth expectations. B. Riley, JPMorgan and Canaccord cited record Q4 execution, with revenue up 12% sequentially and adjusted EBITDA exceeding guidance, supported by auto insurance strength and new marketing channels. However, Needham, B. Riley, JPMorgan, Canaccord and Raymond James all reduced targets. Needham pointed to below-consensus Q1 guidance as insurance carriers adopt more disciplined spending after strong Q4. Raymond James flagged sector-wide pressure from AI displacement concerns. The company guided first-quarter 2026 revenue between $175 million and $185 million. Analysts noted durable growth, margin expansion and strong cash flow, though near-term revenue uncertainty persists.

Yahoo Finance
Mar 11th, 2026
Ryan Specialty and MediaAlpha are small-cap stocks to target, while EverQuote lags behind

MediaAlpha, an insurance marketplace technology platform, has demonstrated strong momentum with 69.4% annual revenue growth over the past two years. The company, which connects insurance carriers with consumers, is trading at a market capitalisation of $544.6 million. The platform processes nearly 10 million consumer referrals monthly across property, casualty, health and life insurance products. Forecasted revenue growth of 11.8% for the next 12 months suggests sustained momentum. Earnings per share growth of 564% annually has significantly outpaced revenue expansion, indicating improving profitability as the business scales. Ryan Specialty, a wholesale insurance broker founded in 2010, posted impressive metrics including 21.2% annual revenue growth and a robust 19.2% free cash flow margin. The company trades at $4.73 billion market capitalisation.

Yahoo Finance
Feb 27th, 2026
Duolingo stock tumbles 17% after missing full-year guidance despite beating EBITDA expectations

Several growth stocks fell after January's Producer Price Index rose 0.5%, significantly above the 0.3% forecast, with core PPI jumping 0.8% versus expected 0.3%. The hotter-than-expected wholesale inflation data raised concerns the Federal Reserve may delay interest rate cuts, weighing particularly on growth-oriented technology sectors. Duolingo fell 17.4% after reporting disappointing fourth-quarter results, with full-year revenue and EBITDA guidance missing Wall Street estimates, despite beating EBITDA expectations and expanding its user base. Other affected stocks included Carvana, down 5.5%; Revolve, down 5.7%; EverQuote, down 5.5%; and Fiverr, down 7.4%. The prospect of prolonged higher interest rates reduces the present value of future earnings for growth companies, prompting the broad-based sell-off.

The Associated Press
Feb 23rd, 2026
EverQuote achieves record $692.5M revenue in 2025, up 38% year-over-year

EverQuote, an online insurance marketplace, reported fourth quarter revenue of $195.3 million, up 32% year-over-year, with GAAP net income reaching $57.8 million. The net income included a $38.4 million one-time deferred tax benefit from releasing a valuation allowance. Adjusted EBITDA grew 32% to $25.1 million. For full year 2025, revenue increased 38% to $692.5 million, whilst adjusted EBITDA jumped 62% to $94.6 million. The company generated $95.4 million in operating cash flow and ended the year with $171.4 million in cash. Automotive insurance accounted for $629.8 million in annual revenue, whilst home and renters insurance contributed $62.7 million. For Q1 2026, EverQuote forecasts revenue of $175 million to $185 million and adjusted EBITDA of $23.5 million to $26.5 million.

INACTIVE