Full-Time

Insurance Manager I

Posted on 11/1/2025

Deadline 12/12/25
KeyBank

KeyBank

1,001-5,000 employees

Provides banking, loans, and financial services

No salary listed

Overland Park, KS, USA

Hybrid

Hybrid role; must reside in the Kansas City area; minimum three days in-office per week.

Category
Operations & Logistics (2)
,
Required Skills
Management
Requirements
  • Minimum five years of leadership experience.
  • Minimum three years of management experience.
  • Excellent verbal and written communication skills.
  • Excellent time management and organizational skills.
  • Ability to manage change and foster teamwork.
  • Ability to function in a “deadline driven” environment and prioritize responsibilities.
  • Ability to work in a team environment and motivate others.
  • Strong interpersonal skills and professional conduct.
  • Efficient in the use of Microsoft Office Suite.
Responsibilities
  • Lead a designated insurance servicing team.
  • Impart the KeyBank Values and consistently convey the vision and culture to their team.
  • Provide coaching and training in all insurance processes.
  • Act as a primary resource of professional development to members of the team.
  • Conduct periodic audits of the insurance loan-servicing file looking for special conditions, non-compliant items and requirements that may be problematic, bringing them to the attention of the assigned Insurance Specialist for resolution.
  • Provide oversight to their team in performing insurance compliance at policy renewal; in the preparation and case write ups of insurance waivers; processing insurance premium disbursements; and preparation for necessary lender placement of insurance deficiencies.
  • Provide resources and guidance to their team as needed to resolve escalated matters or customer service issues with borrowers, insurance agents, internal clients, and/or insurance companies or discrepancies related to insurance.
  • Prepare monthly team reporting to the Department Manager.
  • Assist Management team with the review and approval of premium disbursements, lender place reviews, internal and external audits, and assumptions.
  • Assist Management team with periodic interviews and new employee training as needed.
  • Interact with internal departments and external customers as needed to resolve any issues or discrepancies related to insurance.
Desired Qualifications
  • Experience with broad based commercial property and liability insurance.
  • Commercial loan servicing experience.
  • Experience with McCracken/Strategy loan servicing system.
  • Prior experience with legal document review and interpretation.
  • Four-year college degree.

KeyBank provides a full range of banking services for individuals, small businesses, and commercial clients across the United States. It offers checking and savings accounts, credit cards, mortgages, loans, and other financial products. Customers use these products by making deposits, borrowing money, or using credit in everyday life; the bank earns interest on loans, fees for services, and commissions on products. KeyBank differs from many rivals by offering a wide geographic footprint and a focus on tailored financial solutions plus tools to improve financial wellness, such as budgeting resources and planning guidance. Its goal is to help clients reach financial milestones—like buying a home, paying down debt, or saving for the future—through a comprehensive set of services.

Company Size

1,001-5,000

Company Stage

IPO

Headquarters

Massachusetts

Founded

1824

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • Q1 2026 net income surged 33% to $486M with 10% revenue growth.
  • Commercial loans hit $107.7B, up $3.4B YoY, fueling interest income.
  • Acquired Clearwater UK, expanding investment banking into Western Europe.

What critics are saying

  • Net charge-offs reach $101M in Q1 2026 from rapid commercial expansion.
  • CRE concentration in $107.7B loans triggers collapse like NYCB in 2024.
  • PNC poaches Midwest clients, undermining Tony Catalina's Michigan push.

What makes KeyBank unique

  • KeyBank specializes in middle-market firms with $10M-$1B revenues across 15 states.
  • KeyBanc Capital Markets delivers syndicated finance and M&A advisory nationally.
  • Targets family offices and private equity with dedicated national teams.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

Medical, dental, & vision

Wellness Programs

Fitness Reimbursement

Alternative Work Schedules

PTO

Parental Leave

401(k) Savings Plan

Discounted Stock Purchase Plan

Tuition Reimbursement

Company News

National Today
Apr 8th, 2026
Cane Capital Partners buys $1.3M stake in KeyCorp with 62,105 shares

Cane Capital Partners LLC has purchased a new stake of 62,105 shares in KeyCorp, valued at approximately $1.28 million, according to a regulatory filing. The institutional investor acquired the shares during the fourth quarter of 2025. KeyCorp is a Cleveland-based financial services company providing retail and commercial banking products. The investment reflects institutional confidence in the regional bank's growth potential and business prospects. The purchase signals that institutional investors see value in KeyCorp's stock performance and future outlook in the financial services sector.

PR Newswire
Apr 2nd, 2026
Brookdale Announces Successful Refinancing Transaction; Extends 2027 Non-Recourse Mortgage Debt Maturity

/PRNewswire/ -- Brookdale Senior Living Inc. (NYSE: BKD) ("Brookdale" or "the Company") announced today the Company completed a successful refinancing...

Cintas
Mar 11th, 2026
CINTAS TO ACQUIRE UNIFIRST IN $5.5 BILLION TRANSACTION THAT EXPANDS SERVICE CAPABILITIES, ENHANCES WORKDAY SOLUTIONS AND ADVANCES INDUSTRY INNOVATION

Transaction expected to deliver substantial benefits for customers, workers and employees across North America and enhance value for shareholders of both companies.

Yahoo Finance
Feb 27th, 2026
KeyBank targets 10% commercial banker workforce growth for second consecutive year

KeyBank is targeting a 10% increase in its commercial banking workforce this year, following an 11% expansion in 2024. The Cleveland-based regional bank recently hired a five-person family office and private capital team in Kansas City to support the growth initiative. The bank currently employs 181 commercial bankers serving middle-market businesses generating between $10 million and $1 billion in revenue. Two teams hired last year in Chicago and Southern California have driven new customer growth and loan production at roughly twice the rate of the rest of the portfolio, according to Ken Gavrity, head of Key's commercial bank. KeyBank's commercial division generated approximately $2.1 billion in revenue last year, representing nearly one-third of total revenue. The bank is particularly focused on expanding in the Southeast, with Atlanta under consideration.

PR Newswire
Feb 9th, 2026
KeyBank adds five-person family office banking team to expand middle market capabilities

KeyBank has hired a five-person family office and private capital team led by Ward Nixon to expand its middle market capabilities. Nixon joins as Commercial Leader based in KeyBank's Overland Park, Kansas office. The team will provide national coverage serving family offices and private equity sponsors across direct investments, portfolio company banking, and wealth management. Nixon brings extensive experience in commercial banking and leveraged finance across multiple US regions. The hire follows KeyBank's successful team additions in Chicago and Southern California in late 2024. The move reflects KeyBank's strategic focus on family offices and private equity firms, which increasingly drive middle market ownership and capital deployment. KeyBank has approximately $184 billion in assets as of December 2025.

INACTIVE