Full-Time

Payroll Senior Manager

Posted on 12/19/2025

Deadline 1/18/26
American Family Insurance Group

American Family Insurance Group

10,001+ employees

Property and casualty insurance provider

Compensation Overview

$99k - $167k/yr

Madison, WI, USA + 2 more

More locations: Boston, MA, USA | Minneapolis, MN, USA

Hybrid

Hybrid; reside within 35-50 miles of Madison WI, Boston MA, or Minneapolis MN; minimum 10 days per month in office.

Category
Accounting (1)
Required Skills
Workday HRIS
Requirements
  • Demonstrated effective leadership skills.
  • Demonstrated knowledge and understanding of federal, state, local compensation and payroll and unemployment taxation laws and regulations for all applicable jurisdictions.
  • Demonstrated understanding of Title III of the Consumer Credit Protection Act pertaining to garnishment of wages.
  • Demonstrated mathematical, communication and project management skills.
  • Residence within approximately 35-50 miles of Madison, WI; Boston, MA; or Minneapolis, MN office locations and ability to work a hybrid schedule requiring a minimum of 10 days per month in the office.
  • Workday payroll experience is preferred but not required.
  • Up to 10% travel.
  • Sponsorship will not be considered unless specified in the posting.
  • Background checks and non-disclosure agreement required.
  • Relocation support offered for eligible candidates.
  • Not applicable licenses; no professional license requirement.
  • Ability to oversee bi-weekly, off-cycle, and bonus payrolls; oversee outsourced payroll tax returns; manage vendor relationships; coordinate with accounting for salary and benefits expense and taxation; implement internal controls.
Responsibilities
  • Creates a collaborative, performance-driven work environment by facilitating and promoting trust, transparency, and inclusion. Work with team members to set clear goals, provide feedback, perform performance assessments, and support ongoing development.
  • Leads with influence and expertise; contribute to division or department leadership team; communicate and support organization mission, vision, values and practices.
  • Researches payroll tax laws and regulations and the impact to the company; work with internal departments to determine impacts of proposed legislative and regulation.
  • Provides oversight and direction for creating the bi-weekly, off-cycle, and bonus payrolls; direct the compiling and computing of payroll data metrics.
  • Consults with compensation and benefits departments to ensure the accuracy of data input, paychecks, taxation and deduction amounts for active and terminating employees.
  • Provides oversight for the preparation and review the outsourced payroll tax returns; review significant portions of the tax returns for accuracy; establish systematic data validations and review of payroll and employee system data.
  • Manages the vendor relationships as they pertain to payroll.
  • Works with the Accounting areas to insure proper financial statement accounting for items which impact salary and benefits expense payments and taxation; implements, maintains, and tests proper internal controls.
  • Develops strategies and supporting arguments that minimize adverse payroll-related audit adjustments and further audit risk; responsible for defense against audits by IRS, state, or local authorities for areas such as: employee federal and state taxable income and tax withholding, taxable fringe benefits recognition, and unemployment insurance payments.
  • Maximize efficiencies for payroll systems and processes by establishing consistent tools and ensuring accurate data inputs and information systems.
Desired Qualifications
  • Workday payroll experience is preferred but not required.
  • Location-based hybrid work requirement and relocation support details may be considered favorable for candidates.
  • Background checks and non-disclosure agreements are standard but not desirable qualifications; they are conditions for the role.
  • Sponsorship restrictions stated; no sponsorship expected.
American Family Insurance Group

American Family Insurance Group

View

American Family Insurance Group provides property and casualty insurance across personal and commercial lines. It underwrites and administers policies and risk management services through a multiline insurance model. It differentiates itself with a diversified distribution strategy, including acquisitions like Bold Penguin to offer its own products and those of others. Its goal is to grow into a broader, more integrated insurer by expanding access to property and casualty coverage across multiple channels.

Company Size

10,001+

Company Stage

Debt Financing

Total Funding

$300M

Headquarters

Madison, Wisconsin

Founded

1927

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • AM Best affirmed A rating in September 2025 amid industry challenges.
  • Reported $21.339B revenues and $2.478B profits in latest fiscal year.
  • Ranks 10th largest U.S. P&C group with $19.6B 2024 written premiums.

What critics are saying

  • Direct-to-consumer channels like Homesite cannibalize 2,400 agents' revenues now.
  • Bold Penguin erodes underwriting discipline by selling rival policies immediately.
  • Arturo licenses AI to competitors, degrading AmFam's edge within 12 months.

What makes American Family Insurance Group unique

  • Bold Penguin acquisition enables selling competitors' products via diversified distribution.
  • Arturo AI spin-out provides proprietary property analytics for risk assessment.
  • Four Lakes Re 2022 cat bond upsized to $125M transfers catastrophe risk efficiently.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Your Connections

People at American Family Insurance Group who can refer or advise you

Benefits

Health Insurance

Dental Insurance

Vision Insurance

401(k) Company Match

401(k) Retirement Plan

Paid Vacation

Paid Holidays

Student Loan Assistance

Parental Leave

Company News

Global Legal Chronicle
Feb 20th, 2024
Four Lakes Re Ltd.’s US$175 Million Catastrophe Bond Issuance

Conyers, alongside Mayer Brown LLP, advised Four Lakes Re Ltd. on the issuance. Special purpose insurer Four Lakes Re Ltd. announced its new US$125 million Series …

Business Wire
Feb 17th, 2023
Arturo Announces Seed Series Close and Spin-out from American Family Insurance

Arturo, an artificial intelligence powered property analytics startup, announces the close of Seed Series and spin-out from American Family Insurance.

Artemis
Dec 21st, 2022
AmFam raises Four Lakes Re 2022 cat bond target to $125m, pricing at top-end - Artemis.bm

American Family Mutual Insurance Company, or AmFam as it is abbreviated, is hoping to upsize its latest catastrophe bond issuance, with the new Four Lakes

Technical.ly
Sep 24th, 2020
This Week in Jobs, PTW20 Reboot Edition: Get Introduced to your new career

A bonus TWIJ for the all-virtual, mid-Atlantic-spanning Philly Tech Week.

Technical.ly
May 6th, 2020
Here’s the full schedule for Technical.ly’s Introduced|Virtual conference on May 7

The first in our new online series officially kicks off the 10th annual Philly Tech Week presented by Comcast. Join us for this daylong event that introduces you to the ideas, people and opportunities that build better companies.

INACTIVE