Full-Time

Claims Adjuster

Subrogation

Posted on 9/23/2025

Pie Insurance

Pie Insurance

501-1,000 employees

Tech-driven workers' comp for small businesses

Compensation Overview

$70k - $90k/yr

Remote in USA

Remote

Applicants must reside in the United States; territories excluded.

Category
Finance & Banking (1)
Requirements
  • 2+ years experience in Workers' Compensation and/or Commercial Auto claims subrogation.
  • Strong knowledge of insurance claim procedures.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills.
  • Strong decision making and critical thinking skills.
  • Strong negotiation skills.
  • Ability to work in a fast paced environment with accuracy.
  • Ability to learn quickly and take on new challenges and responsibilities.
  • G-Suite Tools, Collaboration tools, Microsoft Office suite.
  • High School diploma or GED required, Bachelor's Degree preferred.
Responsibilities
  • Claim Analysis: Conduct additional investigations, including securing newly developed evidence, to maximize subrogation recoveries cost-effectively for all lines of business.
  • Determine the amount of potential subrogation recovery.
  • Develop and implement a subrogation strategy and action plan for each assigned subrogation claim.
  • Evaluate liability and conduct additional investigations, as warranted, in order to settle claims at optimal levels.
  • Communication: Collaborate and communicate with front line adjusters to determine the most appropriate outcome, providing new facts as they become available and an analysis of their impact on the liability and settlement options.
  • Issue subrogation notices in accordance with state specific regulations.
  • Provide detailed updates on subrogation status to relevant stakeholders.
  • Maintain proactive and collaborative contact with insureds, claimants, adverse third parties, attorneys, and front-line adjusters to optimize the recovery process.
  • Document subrogation action plan and recovery status in claim notes.
  • Negotiation and Recovery: Negotiate worker’s compensation and commercial auto subrogation claims with carriers, other responsible party(s), and other legal representatives or attorneys on liability and/or damages.
  • Assist in the recovery of claim overpayments.
  • Negotiate and compromise claim/lien settlement amounts based on the facts of each case.
Desired Qualifications
  • Bachelor's Degree preferred

Pie Insurance provides workers’ compensation insurance for small businesses. Its product uses data-driven technology to underwrite and price policies, delivering fast, online access with quotes in about three minutes. The platform processes, underwrites, and issues workers’ comp coverage, with nationwide availability across 38 states and Washington, D.C., offering potential savings of up to 30% and straightforward terms for small business owners.

Company Size

501-1,000

Company Stage

Series D

Total Funding

$620.3M

Headquarters

Washington DC, District of Columbia

Founded

2017

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • 271% direct written premium growth drives fastest U.S. workers' comp expansion.
  • Audra Foglietta's Chubb expertise boosts financial performance as new CFO.
  • $615M funding since 2017 and 2,800 agency partnerships fuel nationwide scale.

What critics are saying

  • 14% layoffs in 2023 erode morale and trigger talent exodus to GEICO.
  • Funding drought exhausts cash runway without new VC investment.
  • Next Insurance steals market share with broader bundled policy offerings.

What makes Pie Insurance unique

  • Pie Insurance uses data analytics for precise small business workers' comp pricing.
  • Offers 3-minute online quotes and up to 30% savings in 40 states.
  • A.M. Best A-rated coverage revolutionizes traditional insurance processes.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

Competitive cash compensation

Equity

Comprehensive health plans

Generous PTO, including paid sick leave

Future focused 401k match

Generous parental & caregiver leave

Growth & Insights and Company News

Headcount

6 month growth

-14%

1 year growth

-14%

2 year growth

-15%
Yahoo Finance
Feb 8th, 2024
Pie Insurance Integrates with Ivans Download

Pie Insurance integrates with Ivans Download.

Business Wire
Nov 30th, 2023
Pie Insurance Secures $11 Million Series A Funding to Rapidly Expand SMB Workers’ Compensation Insurance Offering

Pie Insurance (www.pieinsurance.com) today announced the completion of an $11M Series A funding round. The round was led by Greycroft, and included pa

FF News
Oct 2nd, 2023
Pie Insurance Appoints Audra Foglietta As Chief Financial Officer

Pie Insurance (“Pie”), an insurtech company specializing in commercial insurance for small businesses, today announced the appointment of insurance executive Audra Foglietta as the company’s new chief financial officer (CFO). Foglietta joins Pie during a pivotal period of growth—Pie is the fastest growing workers’ comp insurer in the U.S.1, achieving a 271 percent increase in direct written premiums, surpassing the growth of all other insurers.Foglietta brings a wealth of financial leadership and strategic expertise to Pie, having spent more than twenty years at Chubb, the world’s largest publicly traded property and casualty insurance company. Most recently, Foglietta served as Chubb’s executive vice president and CFO of Global Operations and Technology, in addition to previously serving as CFO of Westchester Specialty, the company’s excess and surplus division. Foglietta has a proven track record of driving financial performance and operational efficiencies in the public insurance sector. Her expertise includes global business transformations, corporate finance, financial planning and analysis, business analytics and operations.“I’m honored to join Pie as its CFO and be part of an organization that is redefining the small commercial insurance landscape and growing at an impressive rate,” said Audra Foglietta, incoming CFO at Pie. “Pie’s commitment to technology and innovation combined with its dedication to serving the unique needs of small businesses resonated with me

Reinsurance News
Oct 2nd, 2023
Pie Insurance names Audra Foglietta Chief Financial Officer

Pie Insurance, an insurtech company specialising in commercial insurance for small businesses, has appointed Audra Foglietta as the new Chief Financial Officer.

Insurance Innovation Reporter
Aug 25th, 2023
Pie Insurance Expands Leadership Team with Appointments of Four Industry Experts

Carla Woodard, Jaime Gilliam-Swartz, Arash Sadati and Kris Bagchi join Pie's leadership team as Vice Presidents.

INACTIVE