Full-Time

Counsel Management Director

Posted on 8/21/2026

Deadline 8/21/27
AmTrust Financial

AmTrust Financial

1,001-5,000 employees

Multinational property and casualty insurer

No salary listed

United States

Hybrid

Hybrid work model with reporting to an AmTrust office.

JD

Category
Legal & Compliance (2)
,
Required Skills
Data Analysis

Get referred to AmTrust Financial

See people who can refer or advise you

Requirements
  • Juris Doctor from an accredited law school.
  • State Bar licensed attorney.
  • At least 7 years of legal practice experience.
  • At least 5 years of experience in leadership roles supervising attorneys and other legal staff.
  • Prior experience handling insurance defense litigation for insurance carriers, with expertise in workers' compensation claims and litigation preferred.
  • Experience working across multiple applications and technologies.
  • Experience analyzing data and providing business insights to non-technical audiences.
  • Ability to manage multiple priorities in a fast-paced environment.
  • In-depth understanding of claim and claim legal operations.
  • Advanced understanding of litigation strategy and execution for workers' compensation and other lines of insurance, with the ability to adapt litigation understanding to multiple jurisdictions.
  • Ability to collaborate with internal stakeholders, business partners, external customers, and vendors.
  • Commitment to ethics, integrity, and transparency.
Responsibilities
  • Ensure agreements are in place with outside firms regarding adherence to AmTrust litigation, billing, and related guidelines.
  • Communicate changes to approved panel law firms to claim lines of business.
  • Support internal business partners through training and communication on best practices for working with outside counsel.
  • Serve as the primary AmTrust point of contact to coordinate and resolve issues with outside counsel.
  • Work with internal business partners to implement third-party risk management strategies consistent with AmTrust enterprise strategy.
  • Negotiate and manage all outside counsel rate agreements.
  • Evaluate opportunities to implement alternative fee agreements.
  • Develop analytics to identify trends, cost drivers, and improvement opportunities across all categories of legal spend.
  • Define and measure outside counsel performance expectations, including understanding of AmTrust objectives, technical expertise, responsiveness, efficiency, cost and budget predictability, and results.
  • Implement procedures to capture claim feedback about counsel performance at file closing.
  • Create an outside counsel performance scorecard for use by the claim department.
  • Establish a systematic file review process and conduct regular reviews for top panel firms.
Desired Qualifications
  • Expertise in workers' compensation claims and litigation.

AmTrust Financial Services provides property and casualty insurance for businesses through three global segments: Small Commercial Business Insurance, Specialty Risk and Extended Warranty, and Specialty Middle-Market Property and Casualty Program Insurance. Its products work by underwriting and issuing workers’ compensation, general liability, and other specialty coverages tailored to the size and risk profile of small to mid-sized businesses, with policy administration and claims handled within its program structures. The company differentiates itself by targeting niche markets with program-style insurance and a global, diversified mix of standard and specialty coverages. Its goal is to protect businesses from P&C risks while growing market share across its global segments and expanding its specialized programs to new customers and regions.

Company Size

1,001-5,000

Company Stage

N/A

Total Funding

$246.1M

Headquarters

New York City, New York

Founded

1998

Get referred to AmTrust Financial

See people who can refer or advise you

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • Samsung Care+ Canada launched July 13, 2026, expanding partnered distribution and fee income.
  • AmTrust earned Insurance Business America’s 2026 5-Star Claims Excellence award on June 17, 2026.
  • NBS expanded PI placements to £10 million on June 9, 2026 using AmTrust Specialty capacity.

What critics are saying

  • AmTrust’s 2014-2017 securities fraud case remains active, with class certification pending since September 2025.
  • AmTrust is still settling investor allegations for $19 million, exposing governance and disclosure damage.
  • If MGA spin-off integration fails, AmTrust loses fee-business economics while still carrying underwriting risk.

What makes AmTrust Financial unique

  • AmTrust’s December 5, 2025 Blackstone deal locks in 10-year MGA capacity.
  • AmTrust expanded E&S on September 15, 2025, adding property, environmental, and builders risk.
  • AmTrust won Celent’s June 11, 2026 GenAI claims award, signaling claims automation strength.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

Health Insurance

Dental Insurance

Life Insurance

401(k) Retirement Plan

401(k) Company Match

Paid Time Off

Company News

Insurance Age
Jun 9th, 2026
NBS expands PI placements to £10m as AmTrust provides capacity.

NBS expands PI placements to £10m as AmTrust provides capacity. * * By Rosie Simms * 09 Jun 2026 * Indicative reading time: 2 minutes NBS Underwriting has extended its professional indemnity capacity with a partnership with AmTrust Specialty providing an additional £5m excess layer, to streamline placement processes. Combined with its current £5m primary capacity supported by Hadron or Accelerant, the managing general agent noted the facility will enable it to provide PI placements up to the new higher limit. Brokers will be able to access a combined primary and excess layer PI programme through one provider and will have single underwriting contact for the full placement, it underlined. By placing both layers with NBS, Insurance Group can offer a more efficient process and greater continuity across the programme, helping Show password You may also like.

Business Wire
Feb 10th, 2026
AmTrust International launches APRA-licensed insurer in Australia to expand legal expenses coverage

AmTrust International has launched AmTrust Specialty Limited, an APRA-licenced entity in Australia, marking a significant expansion for the global specialty insurer. The move enables the company to scale its Legal Expenses Insurance offering in response to consistent demand from intermediaries, funders and legal professionals. The company will provide After the Event and Before the Event insurance products, supporting individuals and businesses pursuing or defending legal action by covering financial risks. These products will be distributed through insurance intermediaries, litigation funders and solicitors. AmTrust International, a subsidiary of AmTrust Financial Services, specialises in property, mortgage and credit, warranty, professional lines, legal expenses and medical malpractice insurance. The Australian launch reflects the company's long-term commitment to building a sustainable presence in the country's mature legal landscape.

Insurance Journal
Sep 17th, 2025
People Moves: AmTrust Names Fletcher and Thomas to Lead New E&S Premier Group; The Fidelis Partnership Makes Leadership Promotions

AmTrust Financial Services Inc., headquartered in New York City, appointed Curt Fletcher as senior vice president and Matt Thomas as vice president of AmTrust's newly established E&S Premier group within the company's excess and surplus (E&S) division.

Insurance Journal
Sep 16th, 2025
AmTrust Expands E&S Division, Spins Off Some MGAs With Blackstone

AmTrust Financial Services has a busy day on Sept. 15 as it expanded its excess & surplus division to include new lines, appointed leadership, and announced an agreement with Blackstone Credit & Insurance to spin off certain managing general agencies into a new, independent company.

WorkCompWire
Sep 5th, 2025
AmTrust Names Carl Canales EVP, Head of Field Operations for North American P&C

New York, NY - AmTrust Financial Services, Inc., recently announced the appointment of Carl Canales as Executive Vice President (EVP), Head of Field Operations for North American P&C.