Assistant Vice President of Garage Claims

Assistant Vice President, Garage Claims, Argo Group

At Argo Group, we invite you to elevate your career as our new Assistant Vice President, Garage, to join our Claims organization. Based within one of our offices, this leader reports to the SVP, Specialty Claims, and oversees Argo Group’s Garage Claims Department.

Make Your Mark at Argo Group

At Argo, claims professionals use independent judgment to deliver tailored solutions, benefit from direct access to senior leaders, and work in a collaborative, inclusive environment that values creativity and diverse perspectives.

In addition to handling complex files, this role leads experienced Garage claims professionals and drives operational excellence across the department. With oversight of short‑term planning, claims performance, and process optimization, this position directly influences our financial results and service delivery.

How You Will Create an Impact

• Deliver expert claims guidance in Garage lines driving timely and accurate results while shaping cost-effective litigation strategies.
• Champion strong claims management principles, setting and achieving performance goals, and implementing data-driven claim management.
• Lead process improvements, collaborating cross-functionally to boost systems, workflows, and operational efficiency.
• Recruit, coach, and retain high-performing claims professionals, cultivating technical excellence and exceptional service.
• Model Argo’s values, championing strong claims management and a positive, growth-focused culture for lasting organizational success.

What You’ll Need to Succeed

• Bring over a decade of commercial auto garage claims expertise with strong knowledge of bodily injury, including five-plus years leading teams and driving high performance.
• You MUST have significant experience in Garage Claims, including Bodily Injury, as you will be seen as an SME for Underwriting.
• Demonstrate advanced skills in claims resolution, settlement practices, and technical procedures, consistently delivering timely, cost-effective results.
• Exhibit strong business acumen, analytical decision-making, and resilience, thriving in fast-paced environments and adapting to evolving challenges.
• Lead with emotional intelligence, fostering collaboration, providing meaningful coaching, and building strong relationships across teams and partners.
• Communicate confidently with executive leadership and peers, leveraging polished presentation skills and proficiency in MS Office Suite and key business software.

At Argo, we value in-person collaboration as a vital part of our culture, which is why we ask our team members to be primarily in the office five days a week. This approach helps us work together effectively and create a supportive, connected environment for our team and clients alike.

The typical base salary range is $166,000 - $194,000 (based on experience and location). Additionally, this position is eligible for a bonus in accordance with the terms of the applicable incentive plan. We’re proud to offer a range of competitive and comprehensive benefits packages.

Explore Claims Careers at Argo Group

• At Argo Group, claims professionals are valued as essential contributors. The work is challenging, diverse, and impactful.
• Adjusters and Managers have the autonomy to develop creative solutions for each claim. Innovation is encouraged.
• Our flat structure allows direct interaction with senior management, especially for major losses.
• The claims team works collaboratively and rewards creative ideas. Your voice and contributions are recognized. 
• We welcome talented people from all backgrounds to join our inclusive, diverse team.

Information about the specialized underwriting business that generates claims this position will oversee can be found here: Garage Liability Insurance | Transportation | Colony Specialty.