T

The Plexus Groupe

Insurance brokerage and risk advisory

Client Manager - Employee Benefits

Full-Time
$70k - $100k/yr
Mid, Senior
Bachelor's
Chicago, IL, USA+1 moreMore locations: Deer Park, IL, USA
In PersonThe role is based at the Deer Park headquarters; candidates may also be considered for the Chicago office. Travel is required 15% of the time.

About the job

Requirements
  • A BA/BS degree or equivalent experience is required.
  • At least 3 years of client management experience and 5 or more years of general Employee Benefits Brokerage experience are required.
  • A proven professional history of successfully managing client relationships is required.
  • A fundamental understanding of benefit laws, regulations, and compliance standards is required.
  • A State Life and Health Producers license is required.
  • The ability to communicate verbally and in writing with all levels of an organization is required.
  • Excellent attention to detail is required.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Office Suite, especially Excel and PowerPoint, is required.
  • The ability to calculate customized financial analyses and present an interpretation of the data and its meaning is required.
Responsibilities
  • Support the designated team’s business objectives and client management principles so that revenue and profit expectations are achieved.
  • Personally manage a dedicated book of business.
  • Mentor and direct other teammates.
  • Ensure internal workflows are understood and followed across the client management team to promote consistency and achieve quality standards and desired client results.
  • Maintain processes and feedback mechanisms that support client persistency in line with practice expectations.
  • Spend approximately 75% of the time working with and interacting with clients.
  • Maintain honest, straightforward, and open relationships with clients to promote strong working partnerships and client satisfaction.
  • Maintain business partnerships with key carriers and third-party vendors, proactively identify and address issues, and keep the client management team current on vendor changes affecting clients.
  • Stay informed about industry changes, including competitive practices and regulatory or legislative changes, and assess their impact on clients, the Employee Benefits Practice, and the company.
  • Actively support client meetings and presentations to ensure interactions are constructive, thoughtful, and produce expected value and results.
Desired Qualifications
  • An industry professional designation is a plus.

About the company

The Plexus Groupe is an insurance brokerage and risk-management company. The company provides commercial insurance, employee benefits, personal coverage, claims support, and risk advisory services. It serves businesses, organizations, executives, employees, and individual insurance clients. Its operating model centers on advisory teams coordinating carrier markets, account service, claims, compliance, and client risk needs. Teams work across insurance brokerage, account management, benefits, claims, risk consulting, sales, and operations. The organization combines insurance services expertise with practical delivery for business and individual clients.

Company Size

N/A

Company Stage

N/A

Total Funding

N/A

Headquarters

N/A

Founded

N/A

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • Plexus retained Best Practices Agency status in August 2026, validating operating discipline.
  • The firm added Gerald Fawcett, Matthew Stohner, and Michael Newcomb, strengthening executive depth.
  • Membership in Assurex Global broadens international referrals and specialist access for 2026 sales.

What critics are saying

  • Eddie Floyd left for Affordable American Insurance in May 2026, exposing succession fragility.
  • Independent brokers face pricing pressure from Marsh McLennan and Aon during 2026 renewals.
  • A major producer exodus or carrier relationship loss would quickly damage growth and valuation.

What makes The Plexus Groupe unique

  • Gerald Fawcett became president in January 2025, sharpening specialty-practice leadership.
  • Plexus ranked #90 on Business Insurance's 2026 Top 100 U.S. brokers.
  • It keeps Deer Park headquarters with Chicago, Dallas, Oklahoma City, and Tampa offices.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

Flexible Work Hours

Company News

The Insurer
Jan 7th, 2025
The Plexus Groupe promotes P&C leader Fawcett to president, appoints two SVPs

The Plexus Groupe has appointed Gerald Fawcett as president and hired Matthew Stohner as senior vice president of private client solutions.

Plexus Groupe
Oct 1st, 2024
The Plexus Groupe Appoints Michael Newcomb as Chief Financial Officer

The Plexus Groupe appoints Michael Newcomb as Chief Financial Officer.

Plexus Groupe
Aug 22nd, 2024
Intern Allison Clark Selected as The Council Foundation Scholarship Recipient

About The Plexus Groupe The Plexus Groupe is recognized as a 2024 Top 100 U.S. Broker by Business Insurance.

PR Newswire
Aug 7th, 2023
Cary Cheston & Jeff Ruffin Join The Plexus Groupe To Open Memphis Office

DEER PARK, Ill., Aug. 7, 2023 /PRNewswire/ -- The Plexus Groupe, a Top 100 insurance brokerage and advisory firm, has announced the opening of a new office in East Memphis, Tennessee, naming Cary Cheston and Jeff Ruffin, long-time Memphis community members, to their growing list of industry leading brokers. Expanding their presence in the mid-south market to better serve their clients and strategically grow their mid-market operations, Plexus is excited to support the flourishing Memphis community with its unique blend of advanced resources and personalized service.Cary Cheston Jeff Ruffin"Having personally resided in the area for four decades, I have a deep connection to this community," said Eddie Floyd, Chief Operating Officer, The Plexus Groupe. "The first 20 years of my insurance career were in Memphis. Similarly, Brian Morgan, Plexus President and Chief Growth Officer, has personal ties to Memphis, residing there while overseeing a top national brokerage. The spirit of Memphis runs through our veins."Cary Cheston, who will oversee the Memphis office, joins Plexus as Vice President, Business Development & Resident Leader

PR Newswire
Jun 1st, 2023
The Plexus Groupe Names Eddie Floyd And John Dwyer As New Equity Partners

DEER PARK, Ill., June 1, 2023 /PRNewswire/ -- The Plexus Groupe, a Top 100 insurance brokerage and advisory firm, has added Eddie Floyd, Chief Operating Officer, and John Dwyer, President of Employee Benefits, as new equity partners.Eddie joined Plexus this past February, bringing a wealth of knowledge and experience to the company with over 20 years in the insurance industry. His current focus is developing operational efficiencies that benefit our associates and clients. John has been with Plexus since 2014 and was promoted last year to President of Employee Benefits, overseeing national operations. Under John's leadership, Plexus Employee Benefits practices have performed at the highest level."I am excited about the addition of Eddie Floyd and John Dwyer, as equity partners at The Plexus Groupe, as we continue building our firm as a leader in insurance brokerage services" said Founder and CEO, Walter R. Fawcett, III.Eddie and John join other Plexus equity partners who are committed to growth and delivering transformative solutions for their clients.About The Plexus GroupeThe Plexus Groupe is an independent insurance advisory firm backed by subject matter experts, innovative resources, and our own international network. They offer defined practice specialties in Employee Benefits, Property & Casualty, Private Client, Retirement Plans, and Benefit Administration Technology