Full-Time

Property Claims Specialist

Posted on 8/19/2025

Coterie

Coterie

51-200 employees

Digital commercial insurance platform offering underwriting

Compensation Overview

$75k - $100k/yr

No H1B Sponsorship

Remote in USA

Remote

Category
Operations & Logistics (2)
,
Requirements
  • Ability to work regular work the core hours of Monday-Friday 8:00am-5:00pm in your time zone. Additional off hours may be needed pending business needs.
  • 5+ years of work experience at an insurance company and/or insurance claims loss adjustment service provider resolving property and casualty claims.
  • Considerable working knowledge of insurance industry and insurance claims operations particularly around commercial property and casualty claims, policy construction, ISO Commercial BOP forms.
  • Proper adjuster licensing in all applicable states.
  • Legal concepts and processes knowledge base.
  • Exceptional communication (written and verbal), influencing, evaluation, negotiating, listening, and interpersonal skills to effectively develop productive working relationships with internal/external peers and other professionals across organizational lines.
  • Strong time management and organizational skills.
  • Ability to take part in active strategic discussions.
  • Excellent collaboration skills, self-motivated and willing to take initiative.
  • Able to understand and synthesize day to day work within the team into trends, themes, successes and opportunities over periods of time.
  • Strong negotiation and persuasion abilities.
  • Exceptional interpersonal and client service skills.
  • Detail oriented and superior organizational skills.
  • Team player with the ability to collaborate with others.
  • Ability to work independently, with support, in a fast-paced, evolving environment.
  • Hands-on experience and strong aptitude with Microsoft Office.
Responsibilities
  • Develop and implement strategy to drive resolution of Commercial Property claims of moderate to higher levels of severity and complexity, but may be required to handle volume.
  • Coordinate and collaborate with cross-functional Coterie team members on process, product, project, insurance, and other global enterprise initiatives.
  • Investigate claim and review the insureds' materials, documents, reports etc.
  • Identify and assess coverage issues, draft coverage position letters, and retain coverage counsel, when necessary as well as review coverage counsel's opinion letters and analysis.
  • Develop and implement strategy relative to coverage issues which correlate with the overall strategy of matters entrusted to the handler's care.
  • Analyze coverage and damages for purposes of estimating, assessing and recommending reserves.
  • Maintain a diary of all claims, post reserves in a timely fashion, and expeditiously respond to claims inquiries from insured, counsel, underwriters, brokers, and senior management.
  • Negotiate resolution of claims.
  • Analyze, and direct initial risk transfer, subrogation action, additional insured issues, and contractual indemnity issues, to ensure equitable contribution across all claim stakeholders.
  • Prepare and present written/oral reports to senior management setting forth all issues influencing evaluation and recommending reserves.
Desired Qualifications
  • College degree (preferred)
  • Previous experience supporting a business through explosive growth
  • Quality Assurance (QA), Continuous Process Improvement (CPI), User Experience (UX/UI), Design Thinking, Lean, Agile, Project Management (PM), and/or Product Owner (PO) experience
  • AIC and PTC designations a plus

Coterie Insurance provides a digital commercial insurance platform aimed at small businesses, startups, pre-revenue, and home-based ventures. It enables online quoting and binding of policies through a digital underwriting platform, with easy integration to a company’s existing systems via robust APIs. The product works by offering fast, online insurance applications and bindings supported by a network of local agents and brokers who ensure appropriate coverage. What sets Coterie apart is its combination of a dedicated digital underwriting engine, seamless API integration, and active agent/broker support to simplify the entire buying process. Its goal is to make commercial insurance faster, simpler, and more reliable for small businesses through technology and service.

Company Size

51-200

Company Stage

Series B

Total Funding

$97M

Headquarters

Appleton, Wisconsin

Founded

2018

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • Allianz X leads Series C, expanding reinsurance and AI-driven underwriting nationwide.
  • Mark Seich's 2025 CRO appointment accelerates growth in independent agency channel.
  • Simply Business partnership expands BOP coverage to all 50 states digitally.

What critics are saying

  • Next Insurance captures 40% more quotes with superior AI and aggressive pricing.
  • Hiscox direct platform undercuts premiums, poaching Coterie's agent partners.
  • Allianz Re cuts capacity on rising cyber claims, forcing 15-20% rate hikes.

What makes Coterie unique

  • Coterie uses 100% digital underwriting pulling 1200 data points from eight sources for instant quotes.
  • SimplyBind dashboard prefills quotes with business name and address, saving agents 75% time.
  • My Digital Agency enables automated quoting, binding, and lead generation for independent agents.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

Health Insurance

Dental Insurance

Vision Insurance

Life Insurance

Health Savings Account/Flexible Spending Account

401(k) Retirement Plan

401(k) Company Match

Unlimited Paid Time Off

Paid Vacation

Paid Holidays

Continuing education annual stipend

Remote Work Options

Growth & Insights and Company News

Headcount

6 month growth

1%

1 year growth

0%

2 year growth

-1%
The Associated Press
Jan 22nd, 2026
Coterie Insurance appoints Mark Seich as chief revenue officer to accelerate growth

Coterie Insurance, a tech-enabled managing general agent specialising in commercial property and casualty insurance for small businesses, has appointed Mark Seich as Chief Revenue Officer. Seich will oversee revenue strategy across distribution, agency engagement, marketing and customer experience to accelerate profitable growth in the independent agency channel. Seich brings over 15 years of insurance leadership experience. He previously served as VP of Marketing & Distribution at The Philadelphia Contributionship and held senior roles at Berkley Fire & Marine, where he drove digital quote-and-bind initiatives and distribution strategies that delivered significant premium growth. The appointment follows Coterie's recent expansion of its executive team, including additions of a Chief Technology Officer and Chief Platform Officer last year, as the Wisconsin-based company scales its digital underwriting platform nationwide.

Coverager
Sep 11th, 2025
Allianz X Invests in Coterie Insurance

Allianz X, the investment arm of Allianz Group, has made a strategic equity investment in Coterie Insurance, a small business insurance startup. Prior to this, Coterie raised nearly $100 million. Allianz X is leading Coterie's Series C investment and plans to expand its reinsurance relationship with Allianz Reinsurance. This partnership aims to leverage AI-driven underwriting to enhance Coterie's growth in the SMB insurance market.

Insurance Journal
Aug 11th, 2025
People Moves: Coterie Insurance Names Albert and Egbert to Senior Leadership Team

Coterie Insurance, headquartered in Appleton, Wisconsin, named Mike Albert and Allan Egbert to the company's senior leadership team as chief technology officer and chief platform officer, respectively.

PropertyCasualty360
Jun 9th, 2025
Who's using what in P&C insurance: June 9, 2025

ZestyAI partnered with Kin Insurance, a direct-to-consumer, digital home insurance provider committed to serving catastrophe-exposed markets.

Insurance Business
Dec 19th, 2024
Simply Business partners with Coterie Insurance to expand BOP coverage

Simply Business, a digital insurance marketplace focused on small businesses, has partnered with Coterie Insurance to expand its business owner's policy (BOP) coverage nationwide.

INACTIVE