Full-Time

Workers Compensation Claims Supervisor

NJM Insurance Group

NJM Insurance Group

1,001-5,000 employees

Mutual property and casualty insurer

Compensation Overview

$88.2k - $111.2k/yr

Hammonton, NJ, USA

In Person

Based in the Hammonton office with occasional travel to other company locations.

Bachelor's

Category
Insurance (1)
Required Skills
Microsoft Office
Word/Pages/Docs
Quality Assurance (QA)
Excel/Numbers/Sheets

Get referred to NJM Insurance Group

See people who can refer or advise you

Requirements
  • A high school diploma or GED equivalent.
  • Five to eight years of claims handling experience with sound knowledge of workers compensation regulations and case law.
  • Sound litigation management skills and the demonstrated ability to evaluate, negotiate, and settle litigated claims, including or developing knowledge of alternative settlement techniques such as CP liens, medical liens, medical set-asides, and annuity options.
  • The ability to assist, support, and strategically manage complex legal cases.
  • Customer-service orientation with strong written and oral communication skills.
  • Demonstrated leadership, coaching, mentoring, and teamwork skills.
  • Proven critical-thinking skills demonstrating analysis, judgment, and sound decision-making with attention to detail.
  • Experience using an automated claim-processing system and Microsoft Office tools, including Word, Excel, and PowerPoint.
  • Strong organizational skills and the ability to work independently and prioritize responsibilities.
  • The ability to travel occasionally for business purposes.
  • Multi-state experience and/or licensing, including Maryland, Connecticut, Delaware, Pennsylvania, and/or New York.
Responsibilities
  • Develop, recommend, and implement departmental objectives consistent with company business goals, guidelines, and programs.
  • Assist with developing and executing strategic and operational goals and objectives for the Workers Compensation Claims department.
  • Recommend process improvements to improve departmental and staff efficiency, work product, and service commitment.
  • Use quality-assurance and key performance indicator reports to maximize performance, identify and correct performance issues, and provide staff development opportunities.
  • Lead team meetings and facilitate training, including one-on-one staff meetings, to coach staff toward success and promote effective communication.
  • Direct claims staff through technical aspects and support proactive execution of action plans to resolve claim issues and concerns and move cases toward closure.
  • Recognize and investigate subrogation opportunities for recovery of third-party funds and direct staff to pursue further information.
  • Ensure quality management of claims according to claims best practices and company guidelines, including timely and accurate documentation of claim activity.
  • Collaborate with internal resources, including legal staff, the Special Investigations Unit, and Medical Services, to resolve or settle cases in a timely manner.
  • Provide technical direction and ongoing guidance through effective diary management.
  • Negotiate settlements within granted authority and periodically attend claim mediations and settlement conferences.
  • Ensure appropriate case reserves for 90-day and credit reviews consistent with company guidelines.
  • Assist staff with preparing for, attending, and conducting claim reviews.
  • Partner with claim account teams to manage large-account assignments and develop rapport, trust, and expectations regarding servicing requirements.
  • Maintain working knowledge of jurisdictional requirements, forms, and applicable case law for each state serviced.
  • Participate in the outside defense counsel evaluation process and firm selection.
  • Apply critical thinking and multiple perspectives to different situations, strategically consider ways to mitigate exposures, collaborate with staff, and establish plans of action.
  • Apply the company Code of Business Conduct and Ethics and relevant compliance policies, procedures, standards, and laws in performing job responsibilities.
Desired Qualifications
  • A Bachelor's degree and/or five to eight years of equivalent work experience, preferably in an insurance-related industry.
  • Previous leadership experience with a proven record of team building, goal achievement, and superior customer service.
  • Professional designations such as CPCU, ARM, or AIC.

NJM Insurance Group provides property and casualty insurance mainly in the Mid-Atlantic, focusing on auto and home coverages and other P&C protection. It operates as a mutual insurer owned by its policyholders, using premium dollars to fund coverage, claims, and service rather than paying dividends to outside owners. Customers get protection through policies (notebook of auto and home insurance) and a claims process backed by financial stewardship and strong service. NJM differentiates itself by its mutual ownership model and a commitment to value-based solutions and service, plus regional recognition for auto claims experience and employer awards (e.g., leading Mid-Atlantic auto insurer in J.D. Power 2025 AIS; Forbes Best In-state Employer 2019–2025). Its stated goal is to provide value-based insurance solutions with the highest levels of service, integrity, and financial stewardship for policyholders in the Mid-Atlantic.

Company Size

1,001-5,000

Company Stage

Debt Financing

Total Funding

$250M

Headquarters

Trenton, New Jersey

Founded

1913

Get referred to NJM Insurance Group

See people who can refer or advise you

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • June 2026 cat bond raised $250 million, enabling larger catastrophe protection.
  • October 2025 claims certification and Mid-Atlantic ranking support retention and pricing power.
  • 2026 board addition of Joseph S. Colalillo broadens governance and local network access.

What critics are saying

  • Carol Voorhees replaced Mitch Livingston in July 2025; leadership transition disrupts culture.
  • Catastrophe exposure remains concentrated in Northeast states through June 2029 reinsurance tower.
  • A severe coastal hurricane could overwhelm indemnity layers and damage surplus.

What makes NJM Insurance Group unique

  • Mutual insurer keeps policyholder focus, not public-market pressure, under Voorhees since July 2025.
  • Eight straight J.D. Power claims certifications signal operational discipline and service quality.
  • Lower Ferry Re 2026-1 shows strong capital access for Northeast storm risk.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

Health Insurance

Dental Insurance

Vision Insurance

Life Insurance

Disability Insurance

Paid Vacation

Paid Sick Leave

Parental Leave

401(k) Company Match

Growth & Insights and Company News

Headcount

6 month growth

6%

1 year growth

6%

2 year growth

6%
Artemis
Jun 12th, 2026
NJM Insurance secures upsized $250m Lower Ferry Re 2026-1 cat bond - Artemis.bm

NJM Insurance has now successfully secured the upsized $250 million of northeast US named storm reinsurance from the capital markets with its new Lower

Fideri News
Apr 19th, 2026
Ocean City H.S. students to receive DUI prevention simulator training.

Ocean City H.S. students to receive DUI prevention simulator training. Driver education students at Ocean City High School will learn how it feels to drive impaired when they take the wheel of a desktop simulator during training sessions at the school from April 21 through April 28. The simulator sessions are offered through a partnership between the John R. Elliott HERO Campaign, Cape May County Prosecutor's Office, Ocean City Police Department and NJM Insurance. A dedication ceremony for the new simulator will be held Tuesday, April 21, at noon in the high school's Community Room. The computer program challenges students to "drive" through a virtual town, displayed on a video screen, while their responses are altered to resemble intoxication. The effects typically cause students to run through stop signs and traffic lights and even cause virtual accidents. "At first, students enjoy the fun and challenge of the simulator, until they experience problems and realize that drinking and driving is no joke and can have serious consequences," said Bill Elliott, founder and chairman of the HERO Campaign. The John R. Elliott HERO Campaign is named in memory of Bill Elliott's son, who was killed by a drunk driver after graduating from the U.S. Naval Academy in July 2000. "We are proud and honored to be part of the HERO Campaign's efforts to save lives by offering this DUI prevention simulator to high school students," Cape May County Prosecutor Jeffrey H. Sutherland said. "John Elliott would have served his country honorably as a naval officer had he lived. Now his legacy is saving countless lives through the HERO Campaign." The DUI simulator also has a distracted driving module which shows students how even a brief glance at their phone while driving can turn deadly. "We are excited to offer this next generation driving simulation to our driver education students," Ocean City High School Principal Wendy O'Neal said. "It will serve as a cautionary reminder for them to be safe and responsible drivers." NJM Insurance has provided funding for the simulator. "NJM is committed to supporting initiatives that help reduce the risks of teen car crashes and provide resources to encourage safe driving habits," said Erica Rosso, supervisor of the NJM Consumer Safety Partnership and Program. "We are honored to partner with the HERO Campaign to bring this innovative instructional tool to their driver education program." The HERO Campaign partners with high schools and colleges, bar and tavern owners, law enforcement, and NFL and Major League Baseball teams to promote responsible driving. More than 100,000 motorists have taken the campaign's online HERO Pledge to be safe designated drivers. The campaign has also wrapped police cars from 50 departments throughout New Jersey with its blue and gold symbol and message: "Be a HERO. Be a Designated Driver." Jersey shore weekend. 1. 2.

WV News
Aug 21st, 2025
NJM Again Named a Forbes America's Best-in-State Employer

NJM again named a Forbes America's Best-in-State Employer.

ROI-NJ
Jun 11th, 2025
Njm Insurance Named Top Auto Insurer In Mid-Atlantic Region

NJM Insurance Group (NJM) has ranked No. 1 in the Mid-Atlantic Region in the J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Auto Insurance Study (AIS). NJM’s score of 721 (on a 1,000-point scale) is 65 points higher than the regional average.The J.D. Power 2025 U.S

bdtonline.com
Jun 10th, 2025
NJM Insurance Group Named Best Auto Insurer in the Mid-Atlantic Region for Customer Satisfaction by J.D. Power

NJM Insurance Group named Best auto insurer in the Mid-Atlantic Region for customer satisfaction by J.D. Power.