C

Cottingham & Butler

Independent broker delivering P&C & benefits

Sales Leader - New Business & Producer Development

Account ExecutiveConfirmed live in the last 24 hours
Full-timeMadison, WI, USANo salary listed

About the Job

Requirements

  • Have 7–12+ years of experience in commercial insurance, risk management, or a related advisory role.
  • Have a proven record of success in complex, consultative sales environments.
  • Have experience influencing or leading high-stakes new business opportunities.
  • Have a background as a Producer, Account Executive, Marketer, or similar client-facing professional.
  • Be able to coach, influence, and develop others.
  • Have a deep understanding of insurance program design and risk management strategies.
  • Demonstrate executive presence and strong communication skills in client settings.
  • Be a strategic thinker able to shape and win complex deals.
  • Have a collaborative, team-first approach to sales.
  • Be highly organized and adaptable in a fast-paced environment.
  • Be passionate about developing talent while remaining closely engaged in client work.

Responsibilities

  • Partner with producers on qualified opportunities to shape strategy, messaging, and positioning.
  • Lead and participate in key prospect meetings, including discovery and proposal presentations.
  • Elevate the quality and effectiveness of the consultative sales process and its deliverables.
  • Improve close ratios and win rates on complex, high-value accounts.
  • Act as a senior advisor on large or sophisticated opportunities across industries.
  • Guide risk analysis, program design, and overall solution strategy.
  • Collaborate with marketing and service teams to develop competitive, differentiated proposals.
  • Mentor early- and mid-career producers throughout the sales lifecycle.
  • Provide real-time coaching before and after prospect meetings.
  • Refine prospecting strategies, meeting structure, and consultative selling skills.
  • Accelerate producer ramp-up and long-term success.
  • Represent the Wisconsin leadership team in client-facing situations.
  • Enable parallel pursuit of new business opportunities across the region.
  • Increase the sales organization’s responsiveness and effectiveness.

About the Company

Cottingham & Butler

Independent broker delivering P&C & benefits

Cottingham & Butler is a large, privately held U.S. insurance broker focused on property & casualty and employee benefits. It helps clients manage risk by assessing needs, designing and placing insurance programs with carrier partners, and providing ongoing advisory, service, and claims support. Compared with competitors, it differentiates itself through its independence (not owned by carriers), scale, and a promise of consistent, improved outcomes—articulated as Better Every Day: better advice, better service, and better ideas than peers. The company emphasizes challenging conventional wisdom, innovating its services, and improving client results as it grew from 1887 to become the 3rd largest independently held broker. Its goal is to deliver measurable value for clients every day, helping them reduce risk and optimize benefits while maintaining strong growth and industry expertise.

Company size
501-1,000
Company stage
Not listed
Total funding
Not listed
Headquarters
Dubuque, IA
Founded
1987

Recently Posted Jobs

Explore more opportunities at Cottingham & Butler

See more jobs