Full-Time

Total Loss Supervisor

Posted on 9/9/2026

AssuranceAmerica

AssuranceAmerica

Affordable auto and renters insurance

No salary listed

Tampa, FL, USA + 2 more

More locations: Birmingham, AL, USA | Atlanta, GA, USA

In Person

Bachelor's

Category
Insurance (1)
Requirements
  • Five years of property and casualty insurance experience, including a minimum of three years handling total loss claims.
  • Significant knowledge of repair and total loss techniques and statutory requirements.
  • Spanish-English bilingual proficiency.
  • Valid driver's license.
  • Bachelor's degree.
Responsibilities
  • Review and monitor total loss claim inventory to ensure timely handling and resolution.
  • Assign and distribute new total loss claims based on workload and staffing needs.
  • Provide guidance and technical support to adjusters regarding vehicle valuations, settlement calculations, title issues, and coverage questions.
  • Review claim files for quality, accuracy, compliance, and adherence to company procedures.
  • Approve settlement authority within established limits and escalate exceptions as needed.
  • Handle customer, attorney, lienholder, and regulatory escalations related to total loss claims.
  • Monitor cycle times, pending claims, and key performance metrics to identify and address delays.
  • Conduct claim audits and provide feedback to improve claim quality and consistency.
  • Assist adjusters with negotiation of disputed vehicle values and settlement concerns.
  • Oversee title processing, salvage disposition, and lienholder payoff activities to ensure timely completion.
  • Coordinate with appraisal vendors, salvage vendors, valuation providers, and internal departments as needed.
  • Ensure compliance with state regulations, company guidelines, and documentation standards.
  • Conduct team meetings to communicate department updates, performance expectations, and process changes.
  • Provide coaching, mentoring, and performance feedback to team members.
  • Assist with training and onboarding of new total loss adjusters.
  • Track staffing needs, productivity trends, and workload distribution to support operational goals.
  • Prepare and report departmental metrics and trends to management.
  • Participate in process improvement initiatives to enhance efficiency, customer experience, and claim outcomes.
  • Serve as the primary point of contact for complex total loss claims requiring supervisory involvement.
Desired Qualifications
  • Prior supervisory experience.

AssuranceAmerica provides accessible personal and commercial insurance products, with a long-standing focus on lower-cost auto coverage. Customers can obtain auto, commercial auto and renters policies, supported by quoting, underwriting, policy service and claims operations. The company distributes coverage across selected U.S. states and also offers roadside assistance through its motor-club program. Its operating identity combines regulated insurance carriers and customer-service functions within the broader privately held AssuranceAmerica Group, rather than acting only as an online comparison marketplace.

Company Size

N/A

Company Stage

N/A

Total Funding

N/A

Headquarters

N/A

Founded

N/A