Full-Time

Insurance Agent

Inbound Sales

Posted on 8/19/2026

Polly

Polly

51-200 employees

Bundled multi-policy auto and home insurance

Compensation Overview

$60k - $85k/yr

Remote in USA

Remote

Must maintain a dedicated home workspace and reliable wired high-speed internet.

Category
Sales & Account Management (1)
Required Skills
Customer Service

Get referred to Polly

See people who can refer or advise you

Requirements
  • A valid Property and Casualty insurance license is required.
  • At least one year of experience selling auto and home insurance in a call center is required.
  • Experience selling multiple carriers and multiple state coverages is required.
  • Candidates must maintain a dedicated, distraction-free professional home workspace with a dedicated desk.
  • Candidates must maintain availability during assigned work hours and adhere to assigned schedules, including evenings and Saturdays.
  • Candidates must meet established productivity, quality, and performance standards.
  • Candidates must be able to navigate multiple computer systems simultaneously while actively engaging with customers.
  • Reliable high-speed internet with a wired connection from a major internet service provider is required, with minimum speeds of 25 Mbps download and 10 Mbps upload.
Responsibilities
  • Handle an average of 150 inbound leads per month from motivated real-time car buyers without cold calling.
  • Navigate multiple carrier systems while preparing and cross-selling personalized insurance quotes.
  • Provide expert advice and recommendations to customers and clients.
  • Close sales at a strong conversion rate from the inbound lead flow.
  • Foster a strong customer experience at every customer touchpoint.
  • Follow up continuously with warm leads to drive deals to completion.
  • Work assigned full-time schedules based on business coverage needs.
  • Complete four weeks of full-time training consisting of live sessions and independent work.
Desired Qualifications
  • Persuasive, persistent, and confident approach to closing sales in a fast-paced setting.
  • Strong communication, organization, and multitasking skills.
  • Experience with AMS360, PL Rater, or other rating tools.
  • Internet speeds of 50 Mbps download and 25 Mbps upload or higher are recommended.

Polly bundles multiple types of insurance—auto, home, umbrella, boat, motorcycle, and RV—when customers buy a new car, to simplify and reduce insurance costs. It works through partnerships with car dealerships and a nationwide network of licensed agents who collect customer information, help select policies from carrier partners, and finalize a multi-policy purchase in one experience. The business earns commissions from insurance carriers for each policy sold, aligning incentives with selling bundled coverage. Polly differentiates itself by the point-of-sale bundling offered at dealerships, combined with a broad set of insurances and a nationwide agent network, rather than focusing on standalone policies. The company’s goal is to make the insurance buying process easier and more affordable for customers while enabling dealerships and carriers to increase cross-sell opportunities.

Company Size

51-200

Company Stage

N/A

Total Funding

N/A

Headquarters

George Local Municipality, South Africa

Founded

2015

Get referred to Polly

See people who can refer or advise you

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • Q1 2026 showed 22% higher F&I gross when buyers received Polly quotes.
  • Polly said only 2% of buyers struggled to find coverage, reducing purchase friction.
  • Rick Gibbs leads since August 2023, bringing Dealer.com and Cox Automotive operating credibility.

What critics are saying

  • Progressive, State Farm, and GEICO can pressure pricing, compressing Polly’s commission economics in 2026.
  • Polly depends on dealership integrations; any Tekion or CDK workflow shift cuts distribution quickly.
  • If quote demand keeps falling from $202 to $168, dealers may deprioritize insurance.

What makes Polly unique

  • Polly embeds insurance quoting inside dealership workflows, including Tekion, CarNow, and CDK Elead.
  • Polly’s licensed agency model operates in 48 states, combining quotes, agents, and carrier commissions.
  • Its reports tie insurance engagement directly to dealer F&I lift, not just lead generation.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

Health Insurance

Dental Insurance

Vision Insurance

Health Savings Account/Flexible Spending Account

Paid Vacation

Paid Parental Leave

401(k) Company Match

Life Insurance

Disability Insurance

Remote Work Options

Commuter Benefits

Paid Holidays

Growth & Insights and Company News

Headcount

6 month growth

-9%

1 year growth

-9%

2 year growth

-9%
Associated Press
Apr 29th, 2026
Dealerships see 22% higher F&I gross when customers receive insurance quotes

Polly, an embedded auto insurance marketplace for automotive retail, reported that dealerships introducing insurance quotes during vehicle purchases saw 22% higher finance and insurance gross profit, adding $343 per transaction on average. When customers purchased insurance, F&I gross increased 35%, or $564 per deal. The company's Q1 2026 report found that monthly insurance quotes declined to $168 nationally, down from a peak of $202 in Q4 2024. The share of buyers struggling to obtain insurance fell from 15% in early 2024 to just 2% in Q1 2026, signalling market stabilisation. Top-performing dealership partners achieved F&I improvements ranging from 8% to 47%. However, regional disparities persist, with Nevada, New York and Georgia posting premiums significantly above the national median.

Coverager
Aug 26th, 2024
Geico’S Latest Agency Appointment

According to the California and Texas Departments of Insurance,. GEICO <i class="fa fa-info-circle company-popover" data-content="h3GEICO/h3. div

Coverager
Aug 14th, 2023
Polly Has A New Ceo

Insurance startup . Polly <i class="fa fa-info-circle company-popover" data-content="h3Polly/h3. div

Coverager
Jan 18th, 2023
Polly Expands Online Buying Option

Based on information obtained by Coverager, . Polly <i class="fa fa-info-circle company-popover" data-content="h3Polly/h3. div

Business Wire
Jan 17th, 2023
Tekion And Polly Partner To Enhance Consumer Car Buying Experience

PLEASANTON, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Tekion, innovator of Automotive Retail Cloud (ARC), the first and fastest cloud-native automotive retail SaaS platform, today announced a partnership with Polly, the leading insurance marketplace for automotive retail.Through this partnership, dealers can access Polly’s insurance quotes directly from Tekion ARC, seamlessly, in real-time, via Tekion’s Automotive Partner Cloud (APC). Insurance cost savings are presented to the dealership user for easy quoting, then offered to the dealership customer instantly. Consumers not only benefit by saving money on car insurance, they can reinvest these savings to additional products and services for their new car purchase.“Tekion is committed to delivering value to the entire auto retail ecosystem,” says Amit Maheshwari, SVP of Business Development at Tekion. “Our partnership with Polly enables dealers a way to pleasantly surprise consumers during their vehicle purchase by presenting potential cost savings during the FI process while reducing one more step of shopping separately for auto insurance. With the unexpected savings in monthly payment, consumers can elect to purchase additional products and services from the dealership, improving profitability for the dealer. It is a win-win for both consumers and dealers.”“Polly is thrilled to partner with Tekion to integrate our innovative and market-leading digital insurance marketplace into Tekion’s ground-breaking ARC platform for dealerships,” said Wayne Pastore, President and COO of Polly