A

Argo Group

Underwrites specialty insurance and risk management

Property Damage Claims Adjuster - Garage

Full-TimeUpdated on 10/22/2026
$78.3k - $110.5k+ Annual performance-based bonus
Junior
Bachelor's
Richmond, VA, USA+4 moreMore locations: Chicago, IL, USA | Albany, NY, USA | Omaha, NE, USA | New York, NY, USA
In Person100% in-office at a designated company office five days per week.
InsuranceClaims Adjudication
No H1B Sponsorship

About the job

Requirements
  • A minimum of two years' experience adjudicating first- and third-party commercial property damage claims is required.
  • A bachelor's degree from an accredited university is required; two or more insurance designations or four additional years of related experience adjudicating environmental claims beyond the minimum experience requirement may substitute for the degree.
  • Must be licensed, or able to obtain a license within 120 days, in each jurisdiction requiring a license to adjudicate first-party claims.
  • Must have business acumen, including understanding how an insurance company operates and how the role affects profitability for the company and its customers.
  • Must work independently and exercise sound judgment.
  • Must have evaluation, strategic, and claim negotiation skills, including a proactive and pragmatic approach to negotiation.
  • Must have a strong customer focus and be able to determine client needs and provide value-added solutions.
  • Must manage time effectively, prioritize workload, and handle multiple tasks and deadlines.
  • Must be able to articulate the financial value of the work to stakeholders at multiple levels of client organizations, potentially including the chief executive officer.
  • Must regularly exercise discretion and independent judgment on significant matters.
  • Must be able to develop and maintain productive relationships with clients, business partners, and organizational peers, with timely and meaningful information exchanges.
  • Must use listening and questioning techniques to gather information from insureds and claimants.
  • Must understand mechanisms for resolving claims settlement disputes, including arbitration and mediation, and when to use them.
  • Must be proficient in Microsoft Office Suite and other business-related software.
  • Must read and write English fluently.
  • Must be legally authorized to work in the United States.
  • Must be able to work on-site at a designated company office during standard business hours.
Responsibilities
  • Adjudicate higher-technical-complexity Garage property damage claims under technical direction and within assigned limits and authority, with a direct impact on departmental results.
  • Resolve generalized issues that are typically not complex but require understanding a broader set of issues.
  • Gather information, analyze and investigate details to find solutions to numerous and undefined issues.
  • Report claims trends and developments to senior management and underwriters.
  • Identify loss drivers and claims trends to reduce claims frequency and severity through data analysis and improved claim management.
  • Analyze claims forms, policies and endorsements, client instructions, and other records to determine whether losses fall within policy coverage.
  • Investigate claims promptly and thoroughly, including interviewing all involved parties.
  • Manage claims in litigation.
  • Manage the claims diary and complete tasks to support favorable financial outcomes and timely resolution.
  • Set claim reserves appropriately.
  • Identify and assign expert resources, and coordinate their involvement in case resolution.
  • Prepare reports for file documentation.
  • Apply solutions that support favorable financial outcomes.
  • Negotiate timely and effectively within assigned limits, using a range of negotiation styles to develop cost-effective solutions for the company and its customers.
  • Process mail and prioritize workload.
  • Complete telephone calls and written correspondence with insureds, claimants, and other parties.
Desired Qualifications
  • Prior experience with ImageRight, Guidewire, and ClaimsCenter is strongly preferred.
  • Experience working with Guidewire is strongly preferred.

About the company

Argo Limited operates in the specialty insurance space, offering tailored risk management and insurance solutions for clients with complex or niche risks. It underwrites insurance policies, handles claims, and invests premiums to generate income that supports profitability. The company differentiates itself by focusing on niche sectors such as construction, marine, and energy, applying expert risk assessment rather than relying on generic policies. Its goal is to build long-term client relationships through reliable coverage, disciplined risk management, and commitments to corporate responsibility and community engagement.

Company Size

1,001-5,000

Company Stage

Acquired

Total Funding

$1.1B

Headquarters

Pembroke, Bermuda

Founded

1996

Get referred to Argo Group

See people who can refer or advise you

Simplify Jobs

Simplify's Take

What believers are saying

  • Fitch assigned Clearbrook a BBB IDR with stable outlook on December 2, 2026.
  • Management forecasts underwriting improvement in 2026 from specialty lines and expense reductions.
  • Farm Family's results starting in 4Q25 improve Clearbrook's overall financial performance.

What critics are saying

  • Run-off legacy lines still drag results; Fitch expects contraction to reduce adverse impact.
  • The January 2026 rebrand to Clearbrook signals Argo's standalone identity is gone.
  • A 2026 lawsuit against Argo entities shows continuing claims exposure and legal noise.

What makes Argo Group unique

  • Brookfield's 2023 $1.1 billion acquisition gives Clearbrook deep capital and portfolio support.
  • Clearbrook focuses on U.S. specialty P&C, with casualty, environmental, inland marine, and programs expertise.
  • Management added Brookfield-aligned leaders in 2025, including CEO Chris Donahue and COO Arturo Pelaez.

Help us improve and share your feedback! Did you find this helpful?

Benefits

  • Health Insurance
  • Dental Insurance
  • Vision Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Disability Insurance
  • 401(k) Company Match
  • Unlimited Paid Time Off
  • Flexible Work Hours
  • Paid Vacation
  • Paid Sick Leave
  • Paid Holidays
  • Paid Caregiver Leave

Growth & Insights and Company News

6 month growth

3%

1 year growth

3%

2 year growth

3%
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Sep 24th, 2026
Amendment No. 1 to Form S-3

As filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on December 8, 2003

Insurance Journal
Mar 24th, 2025
Argo Group Promotes CFO Donahue to CEO; Chan Now CFO

Argo Group promotes CFO Donahue to CEO; Chan now CFO.

Reinsurance News
Mar 24th, 2025
Argo names Chris Donahue as CEO

With this is mind, David Chan has been named as Argo's Chief Financial Officer, having served as Argo's Chief Accounting Officer since 2022.

StockTitan
Feb 19th, 2025
Willis appoints Helen Campbell Head of Property Wordings in North America

Campbell joins from Argo Group, where she served as Senior Vice President and Head of Contract Wordings.

The Royal Gazette
Oct 16th, 2024
Kevin Madigan joins Argo Group

Bermuda market veteran Kevin Madigan has been appointed as head of Capital Management at Argo Group.