N

NJM Insurance Group

Mutual property and casualty insurer

Subpoena Unit Supervisor

Legal Counsel & Legal SupportConfirmed live in the last 24 hours
Full-timeTrenton, NJ, USA$84.6k - $98.3k

About the Job

Requirements

  • A Paralegal Certificate is required.
  • An Associate’s degree is required.
  • Demonstrated ability to lead, coach, and develop staff effectively.
  • Strong analytical and critical-thinking skills, including the ability to identify issues and implement effective solutions compliant with applicable Rules of Court and law.
  • Excellent written and verbal communication skills, attention to detail, and customer-service orientation.
  • Strong organizational skills and the ability to manage competing priorities, multiple deadlines, and a high-volume workload.
  • Demonstrated experience managing workflow, quality-assurance processes, and performance metrics.
  • Ability to interpret and apply legal, regulatory, and company policies related to subpoena responses and document-production requests.
  • Ability to work independently and collaboratively across multiple departments.

Responsibilities

  • Provide direct supervision and daily workflow management for subpoena staff, including distributing workloads appropriately and ensuring assignments are completed on time.
  • Establish and maintain quality-control standards, performance metrics, compliance with subpoena-response procedures, and document-production standards.
  • Serve as the primary escalation point for complex subpoena, discovery, and litigation-related issues.
  • Coordinate with General Claims Legal attorneys regarding legal and regulatory requirements.
  • Develop employee skills in document review, litigation, and subpoena compliance through coaching and training.
  • Develop, recommend, and implement departmental objectives, workflow enhancements, and operational process improvements.
  • Analyze and report workload, productivity, operational performance, and trends to the Legal Operations Division Administrator and General Claims Legal leadership to support operational decisions and resource planning.
  • Carry out special projects, audits, and other departmental initiatives as needed.

Desired Qualifications

  • Knowledge of subpoena-response requirements, document-retention practices, and legal-document-production processes.
  • Two to four years of supervisory, leadership, or management experience, preferably in a legal or insurance environment.

About the Company

NJM Insurance Group

Mutual property and casualty insurer

NJM Insurance Group provides property and casualty insurance mainly in the Mid-Atlantic, focusing on auto and home coverages and other P&C protection. It operates as a mutual insurer owned by its policyholders, using premium dollars to fund coverage, claims, and service rather than paying dividends to outside owners. Customers get protection through policies (notebook of auto and home insurance) and a claims process backed by financial stewardship and strong service. NJM differentiates itself by its mutual ownership model and a commitment to value-based solutions and service, plus regional recognition for auto claims experience and employer awards (e.g., leading Mid-Atlantic auto insurer in J.D. Power 2025 AIS; Forbes Best In-state Employer 2019–2025). Its stated goal is to provide value-based insurance solutions with the highest levels of service, integrity, and financial stewardship for policyholders in the Mid-Atlantic.

Company size
1,001-5,000
Company stage
Debt Financing
Total funding
$250M
Headquarters
Ewing Township, NJ
Founded
1913

Recently Posted Jobs

Explore more opportunities at NJM Insurance Group

See more jobs